The belief that rising home prices create wealth is a dangerous illusion. Since you must buy another inflated property after selling, you don't actually gain anything. This collective myth primarily serves to lock out first-time buyers and stifle economic mobility for the next generation.
Related Insights
The cultural pressure to own a home can be financially crippling for young professionals. It drains liquid assets for a down payment, reduces career flexibility, and can lock individuals into jobs they hate simply to cover the mortgage. Renting provides more career agility.
High home prices should not be interpreted as a sign of a healthy market. Instead, they indicate a system that is malfunctioning as designed, where artificial scarcity created by policy and corporate buying drives prices up. This reflects a structural failure, not robust economic demand.
A potential silver lining to a severe market correction is that it could solve the affordability crisis. A crash would likely deflate housing prices, curbing inflation. This would implicitly cause a massive redistribution of wealth from older generations who hold home equity to younger generations, breaking economic stagnation through a painful societal shift.
Homeowners who see their property value double aren't actually wealthier. If they sell, they must buy another, equally inflated house. The "gain" is purely psychological unless they relocate to a cheaper area or downsize, which most people do not do.
As homeownership becomes unattainable without generational wealth, social mobility is stalling. The growing gap between asset owners and renters is calcifying, transforming the American economic structure from a meritocracy into a caste-like system where your financial starting point determines your destiny.
Buying a house, especially the largest one you can afford, locks up capital and incurs numerous hidden costs beyond the mortgage (maintenance, taxes, renovations). This inflates your cost of living and hinders wealth creation compared to the simplicity and lower costs of renting.
The true affordability crisis isn't about everyday goods, but the soaring costs of assets essential for upward mobility: housing and education. While wages track inflation for goods, they lag behind the 'price of entry into wealth,' creating deep-seated anxiety.
Schools teach us to earn a salary, not own equity. The home you live in is for making memories, not money, and is an inefficient way to build wealth. True financial independence comes from owning equity in assets that generate income and appreciate in value, a concept rarely taught.
Homeowners and local governments block new development, creating artificial scarcity that drives up prices, similar to how luxury brands like LVMH restrict supply to increase value. This "LVMH-ing" of housing makes it unaffordable for younger generations and limits economic mobility.
The current housing market is not a cyclical bubble that will pop, but a structural crisis. It's a permanent collapse of opportunity driven by policy failures, corporate consolidation, and demographic incentives that have created deep, lasting scarcity, fundamentally changing the nature of homeownership in America.