PepsiCo intentionally hired a leader with a marketing and consulting background to head consumer insights. They rejected the 'promote the best surgeon' model, believing an outside perspective was essential to galvanize the team and connect its work directly to business needs.

Related Insights

During its insights transformation, PepsiCo learned that implementing new technology was a minor hurdle compared to changing employee behavior. The real challenge was shifting the team's mindset from simply 'doing research' to strategically 'maximizing the benefit' of the data.

Instead of using research as an expensive, end-stage 'go/no-go' test, PepsiCo made it a cheap, fast, and low-threshold tool for continuous learning. This shifted insights from a final gatekeeper to an integrated partner available at any point in the creative and innovation journey.

Working for a founder who understands marketing (e.g., a former CMO) creates a high-trust environment. This empowers marketing teams to invest in long-term brand building and creative initiatives that are notoriously hard to attribute, without being handcuffed by demands to prove the ROI of every dollar spent.

To break through industry blindness, Pella created a two-person research team with opposing perspectives: a long-tenured internal engineer and an industrial designer with experience from other top companies. This "oil and water" dynamic was key to their success.

PepsiCo’s CEO won over Indra Nooyi not by criticizing competitor GE, but by acknowledging GE's strengths. He then made a personal commitment ("Count on me") to ensure her unique talents would specifically shape PepsiCo's future. This unconventional pitch built immense trust and highlighted his character as a leader.

Marketing leaders often fail when hiring for functions they don't deeply understand. Success comes when you've done the job yourself first, like Capsule's marketing lead who ran events before hiring a specialist. This first-hand experience allows you to know precisely what "good" looks like and evaluate candidates effectively.

As AI handles more tactical work, the distinction between marketing and insights will blur. The most valuable human skills—interpreting nuance, reading culture, understanding context—will become the core of a converged function focused on deep consumer-centric strategy.

The most effective CMOs see themselves as 'architects of growth.' Their core function is to bridge consumer/human growth opportunities with commercial goals, blending the science of data and the art of creativity to design a holistic, company-wide vision for expansion.

Instead of operating within the confines of a marketing department, marketers should adopt the mindset of the CEO. This means focusing on how to change the customer's mind to achieve the company's ultimate goals, rather than getting bogged down in departmental tactics. This approach leads to more influential and strategic work.

Coach's CMO, hired at Louis Vuitton without luxury experience, used her anthropology background to her advantage. Being an outsider allowed her to question industry norms and see the customer experience with fresh eyes, turning a potential disadvantage into her "superpower."

PepsiCo Hired a Marketer, Not a Researcher, to Lead its Insights Team | RiffOn