Instead of positioning against direct competitors in a saturated category, frame your message against what your customer is *actually* using today. A DAM tool resonated better when it shifted messaging from being a "better DAM" to helping users "move on from Dropbox and Drive."

Marketers often mistake strategic positioning (finding a niche) for true category creation. A new category introduces a solution to a problem customers haven't yet articulated, requiring education on why they need a thing they've never bought before.

Startups often fail by making a slightly better version of an incumbent's product. This is a losing strategy because the incumbent can easily adapt. The key is to build something so fundamentally different in structure that competitors have a very hard time copying it, ensuring a durable advantage.

A slightly better UI or a faster experience is not enough to unseat an entrenched competitor. The new product's value must be so overwhelmingly superior that it makes the significant cost and effort of switching an obvious, undeniable decision for the customer from the very first demo.

Palo Alto Networks insisted on calling its product a "next-gen firewall" despite sales team fears. This forced conversations about replacing incumbents, preventing them from being relegated to a secondary "helper" category and ensuring long-term market leadership.

John Osher didn't try to make a cheaper version of the $80 electric toothbrush. Instead, he positioned the $5 Spinbrush as a superior alternative to the $3 manual toothbrush. This re-framing of the competitive landscape created an entirely new market category.

Instead of inventing a completely new market, position your product as a sub-category of something people already understand (e.g., "like live chat, but for sales"). This "horseless carriage" approach makes innovation digestible by grounding it in a familiar concept, as Drift did.

To sell into a cynical market where previous solutions failed (a "Third Journey"), you can't just be a "next-gen" tool. You must re-educate buyers with precise messaging and a new category name, then instantly prove you're different by delivering undeniable value with minimal effort.

Many 'category creation' efforts fail because they just rename an existing solution. True category creation happens when customers perceive the product as fundamentally different from all alternatives, even without an official name for it. The customer's mental bucketing is the only one that matters.