Amplitude's CEO explains how incumbents counter "feature-not-company" AI startups. They rapidly build the startup's core functionality, give it away for free, and leverage it as a powerful lead generation tool for their existing business, commoditizing the startup's value proposition overnight.
Related Insights
OpenAI embraces the 'platform paradox' by selling API access to startups that compete directly with its own apps like ChatGPT. The strategy is to foster a broad ecosystem, believing that enabling competitors is necessary to avoid losing the platform race entirely.
Tech giants like Google and Meta are positioned to offer their premium AI models for free, leveraging their massive ad-based business models. This strategy aims to cut off OpenAI's primary revenue stream from $20/month subscriptions. For incumbents, subsidizing AI is a strategic play to acquire users and boost market capitalization.
The founder predicts that hyper-specific vertical AI solutions are too easy to replicate. While they may find initial traction, they lack a durable moat. The stronger, long-term business is building horizontal tools that empower users to solve their own complex problems.
Unlike cloud or mobile, which incumbents initially ignored, AI adoption is consensus. Startups can't rely on incumbents being slow. The new 'white space' for disruption exists in niche markets large companies still deem too small to enter.
AI favors incumbents more than startups. While everyone builds on similar models, true network effects come from proprietary data and consumer distribution, both of which incumbents own. Startups are left with narrow problems, but high-quality incumbents are moving fast enough to capture these opportunities.
In a crowded market where startups offer free or heavily subsidized AI tokens to gain users, Vercel intentionally prices its tokens at cost. They reject undercutting the market, betting instead that a superior, higher-quality product will win customers willing to pay for value.
ElevenLabs' CEO sees their cutting-edge research as a temporary advantage—a 6-12 month head start. The real, long-term defensibility comes from using that time to build a superior product layer and a robust ecosystem of integrations, workflows, and brand. This strategy accepts model commoditization and focuses on building durable value on top of the technology.
Incumbents face the innovator's dilemma; they can't afford to scrap existing infrastructure for AI. Startups can build "AI-native" from a clean sheet, creating a fundamental advantage that legacy players can't replicate by just bolting on features.
Perplexity's CEO argues that building foundational models is not necessary for success. By focusing on the end-to-end consumer experience and leveraging increasingly commoditized models, startups can build a highly valuable business without needing billions in funding for model training.
