Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Instead of ignoring harsh feedback, Ben Branson publicly shared a comment calling Seedlip "witch's piss." This self-aware approach created a stronger brand story than any positive review could, leaning into the product's polarizing nature and demonstrating confidence in the face of criticism.

Related Insights

The instinctual reaction to a public attack is defensiveness. Instead, view it as a strategic opportunity. Responding to a significant critique allows you to control the narrative, articulate your position forcefully, and rally your supporters. A well-chosen public fight can significantly boost your brand's stature and visibility.

When the audience points out a quirk, lean into it. Pat Flynn turned comments mocking his thumbs into a signature part of his brand ("Diglett thumbs"), creating an inside joke that strengthens community and makes him more memorable.

Receiving negative or controversial feedback on social media indicates your work is opinionated and differentiated enough to provoke a reaction. Rather than a failure, this is a sign of market impact and having a distinct point of view.

After his first event, negative social media feedback nearly caused the founder to quit Twitter. Advice from experienced CEOs reframed the trolling as a sign of visibility, teaching him that if you're reaching people, you can't only be visible to positive voices.

The 'pratfall effect' suggests that admitting a weakness can increase appeal. For brands, this works best when the admitted flaw cleverly emphasizes a core strength. For example, Buckley's cough syrup's 'It tastes awful. And it works' campaign uses its bad taste to signal its powerful efficacy.

Poppi's founders embraced harsh feedback from *Shark Tank* investor Rohan Oza, who loved their product but hated their "Mother Beverage" branding. This critical assessment, which they admitted they already suspected, was the necessary catalyst for their successful rebrand to the much stronger Poppi brand.

The goal isn't to be universally liked. In the new media landscape, if you don't have people who strongly disagree with you, you're likely not being interesting enough to capture attention. A polarizing brand with passionate fans and vocal critics is far more powerful and visible than one that evokes a lukewarm, neutral response.

A brand that tries to please everyone is memorable to no one. To build a truly strong brand, you must be willing to be disliked by some. Intentionally defining who your customer is *not* and creating polarizing content sharpens your identity, fostering a passionate community among those who love what you stand for.

Seedlip's launch elicited anger and visceral negativity from some consumers. Founder Ben Branson realized this strong emotional response was a sign that his product was genuinely threatening the status quo and creating a new conversation. Indifference is the real enemy of innovation.

When Way's dry shampoo started exploding, the team owned the "foam party" disaster. By reposting customer complaints with humor and creating a "mean reviews" video series, they turned a potential PR nightmare into a memorable, brand-building moment that resonated with customers.