While Trastuzumab deruxtecan (TDXD) is effective in HER2-low breast cancer, there is no evidence that it benefits patients with HER2-low or HER2-intermediate (IHC 2+/FISH negative) gastric cancer. Its use should be strictly limited to truly HER2-positive cases in this disease.

Before starting a second-line HER2-targeted therapy like trastuzumab deruxtecan, it is critical to re-biopsy the tumor if feasible. HER2 status can change after first-line treatment, and confirming persistent HER2 positivity is essential to ensure the subsequent therapy will be effective.

In the increasingly common scenario of gastric cancer with multiple biomarkers (HER2, PD-L1, Claudin), experts recommend a clear hierarchy. Based on data maturity, HER2-targeted therapy is the first choice, followed by PD-L1 immunotherapy, with Claudin-targeted therapy third.

While re-biopsying at disease progression is the "by-the-book" standard to confirm biomarkers like HER2, clinicians acknowledge it is often skipped. The difficulty of obtaining tissue and the desire to provide patients with potential treatment options create a gap between guidelines and clinical reality.

Patients with HER2-positive GI cancers can lose expression after treatment. While re-biopsy is ideal, it's often impractical or risky. In these cases, clinicians find ctDNA analysis of HER2 copy numbers to be a reliable alternative for guiding subsequent treatment decisions.

Unlike breast or lung cancer where a biomarker's effectiveness persists across treatment stages, biomarkers in upper GI cancers often fail to show similar efficacy when moved from one line of therapy to another. This suggests a more variable and rapidly changing tumor biology.

The standard HER2 tests were developed to identify HER2-positive tumors, not to precisely quantify low levels of expression. This creates a diagnostic challenge for identifying patients eligible for HER2-low targeted ADCs, requiring closer collaboration with pathology to interpret results that may be near the threshold, such as HER2-zero but with some minimal staining.

Due to selective pressure from first-line treatment, 30-40% of HER2-positive gastroesophageal cancers lose HER2 expression by the time of progression. It is crucial to re-test these patients, either via tissue biopsy or ctDNA, to confirm continued HER2 positivity before initiating second-line HER2-targeted therapy like TDXD.

Experts recommend using the most effective first-line therapy, like zanidatumab combinations, for HER2-positive gastric cancer, despite the risk of the tumor losing HER2 expression upon progression. The substantial upfront survival benefit outweighs the concern of losing a second-line target like T-DXd.