Thiel observes that the less an early-stage CEO is paid, the better the company performs. A low salary (under $150k) paired with high equity aligns the CEO with long-term value creation and sets a culture of shared sacrifice, whereas high pay incentivizes protecting the status quo.
When Nikesh Arora joined Palo Alto, he didn't ask for a raise. He asked for seven years of the previous CEO's pay ($20M/year) granted upfront as stock with a seven-year vest. This single, long-term grant fully aligned him with shareholder value and simplified future compensation discussions.
While 8% of founders pay themselves nothing to maximize reinvestment for a future exit, this strategy is often regretted. Even among founders who achieved a multi-million dollar exit, many later wished they had paid themselves at least a small salary to improve their quality of life during the building phase.
To conserve cash, especially in a downturn, founders can pay key employees 10-30% below market rate in salary. The key is to compensate for this deficit by offering double or triple the industry standard in equity. This strategy attracts top talent aligned with long-term success while keeping the company's cash burn rate low.
Public companies, beholden to quarterly earnings, often behave like "psychopaths," optimizing for short-term metrics at the expense of customer relationships. In contrast, founder-led or family-owned firms can invest in long-term customer value, leading to more sustainable success.
Elon Musk's ambitious, performance-tied compensation plan isn't just about Tesla. It establishes a powerful precedent for other founders, like those at late-stage unicorns, to negotiate for massive new equity grants by tying them to audacious growth targets, reshaping founder incentive structures.
A study found that CEOs trained to prioritize shareholder value deliver short-term returns by suppressing employee pay. This practice drives away high-skilled workers and cripples the company's long-term outlook, all without evidence of actually increasing sales, productivity, or investment.
A business transitions from a founder-dependent "practice" to a scalable "enterprise" only when the founder shares wealth and recognition. Failing to provide equity and public credit prevents attracting and retaining the talent needed for growth, as top performers will leave to become owners themselves.
For a high-skill service business, the biggest barrier to scaling is finding autonomous, high-quality employees. To retain this crucial talent and prevent them from leaving to start a competing business, founders should offer an equity stake that vests over a long period (e.g., 5-6 years), aligning their incentives with the company's long-term growth.
Musk's performance-based compensation sets a precedent for other CEOs to approach their boards with ambitious growth targets in exchange for significant equity increases. This challenges the traditional one-way dilution model for founders and executives.
OpenDoor's CEO takes a $1 salary with compensation tied entirely to performance-based stock. He argues this model directly combats the "scam" of executives getting rich while failing. Traditional cash salaries incentivize inaction, risk aversion, and reliance on consultants to avoid getting fired, ultimately destroying shareholder value.