We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.
Tiffany Jenkins says ancient Romans used public latrines and displayed sexual art, while 1700s England encouraged spying on neighbors' immorality. She dates the modern private sphere to an 1890 article by Samuel Warren and Louis Brandeis, which first argued privacy is essential to the self.
The national outrage over the British government opening an Italian nationalist's mail showcased a profound cultural shift. Victorian society had begun to view private correspondence as sacred and inviolable, a concept foreign to earlier eras.
18th-century novels created a new literary form that explored the passions and ordinary lives of individuals. This cultural shift elevated the private sphere, previously considered unimportant, into a subject of value, fascination, and social anxiety.
The right to privacy originated not from a demand for personal space, but as a necessary political compromise to end centuries of religious bloodshed. Granting freedom of conscience in private paved the way for broader personal freedoms.
We view the surveillance and lack of individuality in *Utopia* as dystopian due to post-Enlightenment values. However, More intended this as a feature. He saw individuality as the sin of pride and designed Utopia to prioritize the public and shared over the private.
The modern, individualistic quest for self-discovery is a recent invention. For most of history, "knowing thyself" meant understanding and conforming to one's prescribed social role within a tribe or community for collective survival and protection.
Before the 17th century, there was little distinction between public and private life. Communities were legally compelled to police their neighbors' morality, and solitude was associated with evil and suspicion, not sanctuary.
Jenkins says private life lets people develop an inner life, think original thoughts, and escape constant public performance. It also gives couples and friends a protected space for vulnerability, and stepping away restores people to engage better in public. She argues it is essential, not merely nice to have.
Jenkins describes a paradox: people post therapy-speak on Instagram stories but cannot discuss money with a partner, and share workouts and makeup routines but feel awkward without makeup around close friends. When everything is public, she says, nothing feels sacred and the exclusive bonds that create intimacy weaken.
In the 19th century, same-sex intimacy was common and did not define a person's core identity. The concepts and words for "gay" or "bisexual" did not exist. People could engage in what we now call queer behavior without being categorized, as the act was separate from a fixed personal identity.
Epitaphs reveal a major cultural shift. Renaissance tombstones listed public roles like 'courtier and soldier,' while 18th-century ones began prioritizing private identities like 'loving husband and father,' a reversal that continues today.