June Cohen cites Mark Mattson of Johns Hopkins saying exercise and fasting can grow new synapses in the hippocampus, the brain area for learning and memory. She argues this neuroplasticity may help someone tell and believe a new story about themselves during a big emotional transition.
Tiffany Jenkins says ancient Romans used public latrines and displayed sexual art, while 1700s England encouraged spying on neighbors' immorality. She dates the modern private sphere to an 1890 article by Samuel Warren and Louis Brandeis, which first argued privacy is essential to the self.
Jenkins says private life lets people develop an inner life, think original thoughts, and escape constant public performance. It also gives couples and friends a protected space for vulnerability, and stepping away restores people to engage better in public. She argues it is essential, not merely nice to have.
Jenkins describes a paradox: people post therapy-speak on Instagram stories but cannot discuss money with a partner, and share workouts and makeup routines but feel awkward without makeup around close friends. When everything is public, she says, nothing feels sacred and the exclusive bonds that create intimacy weaken.
Robin Dunbar's Oxford lab found rowers produced twice as many endorphins when rowing together as alone, Cohen says. She says the same effect appears when people sing in harmony, line dance, laugh together, or even eat together until full to bursting, which helps explain group singing's antidepressant effect.
Cohen says cells repair and brain cells grow during recovery, not during the challenge itself. If you skip that recovery, you skip the growth. She lists recovery alongside structure, meaning, a coach, a witnessing crowd, nature, and a squad as core elements of a well-run challenge.
