To successfully advocate for a working legacy system against modernization pressure, you must be deeply aligned with its profit and loss. If someone else controls the P&L, your customer-centric arguments will be overruled by financial or political motivations, making your position untenable.
Related Insights
A product team saved $150 million in margin improvement not by building new features, but by decommissioning a long tail of customized, on-prem legacy products. This "unsexy" work eliminated significant operational drain from support and maintenance, directly impacting the bottom line in a way new features rarely can.
Business viability is often siloed to executives or sales, but the product manager and their team ultimately pay the price for failure. PMs must own this risk, tracking metrics like the LTV/CAC ratio to ensure the product is not just loved by users but is also sustainable.
To be truly successful, a product leader cannot just focus on features and users. They must operate as the head of their product's business, with a deep understanding of P&Ls, revenue drivers, and capital allocation. Without this business acumen, they risk fundamentally undercutting their product's potential impact and success.
It's not enough to improve engagement or NPS. A product manager's job is to understand and articulate how that metric connects to a financial outcome for the business. Whether it's growth, margin, or profitability, you must explain to leadership why your product goals matter to the bottom line.
True product rebellion isn't disruption for its own sake. It's upholding user needs—which ultimately serve the company—against short-term schemes or departmental politics. This requires strategically giving ground on minor issues to maintain momentum on the most important, long-term goals.
It is a product manager's job to understand the company's financial goals. Instead of waiting for leadership to share this information, great PMs take ownership by actively seeking it out. This means building relationships with finance and other departments to understand the metrics that truly matter to the business.
In a complex legacy environment, internal motivations like improving developer experience or modernizing technology often fail to gain traction. The initiatives that successfully navigate the process are those that can clearly articulate and deliver tangible value to the end customer.
Product managers often fail to get ideas funded because they speak about user needs and features, while executives focus on business growth and strategic bets. To succeed, PMs must translate user value into financial impact and business outcomes, effectively speaking the language of leadership.
The most critical skill gaps for product managers are not technical but relational and financial. The inability to make a compelling business case to diverse audiences and to move from a cost-only to a full profit-and-loss mindset are primary reasons for failure in the role.
Creating products customers love is only half the battle. Product leaders must also demonstrate and clearly communicate the product's business impact. This ability to speak to financial outcomes is crucial for getting project approval and necessary budget.
