While Trastuzumab deruxtecan (TDXD) is effective in HER2-low breast cancer, there is no evidence that it benefits patients with HER2-low or HER2-intermediate (IHC 2+/FISH negative) gastric cancer. Its use should be strictly limited to truly HER2-positive cases in this disease.

Oncologists distinguish between HER2 amplification (the target for ADCs like TDXD) and activating mutations. A patient whose tumor loses amplification but retains a mutation is considered "HER2 mutated," not "HER2 positive," and is generally not a candidate for ADC therapy.

For HER2+ metastatic colorectal cancer, experts choose HER2-targeted therapies like TDXD or tucatinib/trastuzumab over standard second-line chemotherapy (FOLFIRI/BEV), despite label constraints. The rationale is the significantly higher response rate from targeting the oncogenic driver directly.

In the increasingly common scenario of gastric cancer with multiple biomarkers (HER2, PD-L1, Claudin), experts recommend a clear hierarchy. Based on data maturity, HER2-targeted therapy is the first choice, followed by PD-L1 immunotherapy, with Claudin-targeted therapy third.

A subtle finding in the DESTINY-Breast11 trial, where TDXD alone underperformed TDXD followed by THP, suggests that taxane-based chemotherapy might remain effective even after a patient's HER2-positive cancer becomes resistant to the antibody-drug conjugate TDXD.

The success of both MOUNTAINEER (tucatinib/trastuzumab) and DESTINY-CRC02 (T-DXd) has introduced two effective, mechanistically different HER2-targeted therapies. This creates a new clinical challenge for oncologists: how to optimally sequence these agents, as there is no head-to-head data to guide the choice.

Unlike older antibody-drug conjugates (ADCs), newer agents are designed so their chemotherapy payload can diffuse out of the target cell and kill nearby tumor cells that may not even express the target antigen. This "bystander effect" significantly enhances their anti-tumor activity.

In HER2-positive colorectal cancer, the choice of targeted therapy depends on RAS mutation status. The tucatinib/trastuzumab combination is effective only in RAS wild-type patients. In contrast, the antibody-drug conjugate trastuzumab deruxtecan (TDXD) shows efficacy regardless of whether a RAS mutation is present.

Contrary to concerns about cross-resistance between HER2 antibody-drug conjugates (ADCs), retrospective data shows TDM-1 remains effective after progression on TDXD. This suggests the different cytotoxic payloads are key, allowing for effective sequencing and challenging the assumption that progression on one ADC class member precludes using another.