The HER2CLIMB-02 trial found that adding tucatinib to TDM-1 offered only a modest 2-month PFS benefit. This came at the cost of substantially increased toxicity, including transaminitis and diarrhea, suggesting the two agents are better used sequentially for most patients.

Positive data from both DESTINY-Breast09 (TDXD-based) and PATINA (CDK4/6i maintenance) create a new dilemma. With similar PFS outcomes, the first-line choice for metastatic HER2+/HR+ patients now hinges on toxicity profiles and patient preference rather than a single efficacy winner.

For HER2+ metastatic colorectal cancer, experts choose HER2-targeted therapies like TDXD or tucatinib/trastuzumab over standard second-line chemotherapy (FOLFIRI/BEV), despite label constraints. The rationale is the significantly higher response rate from targeting the oncogenic driver directly.

For RAS wild-type metastatic colorectal cancer, oncologists may prefer starting with a trastuzumab/tucatinib regimen over TDXD. This sequencing strategy preserves TDXD as a later option, as there is currently no data supporting tucatinib's efficacy after a patient has progressed on TDXD.

A subtle finding in the DESTINY-Breast11 trial, where TDXD alone underperformed TDXD followed by THP, suggests that taxane-based chemotherapy might remain effective even after a patient's HER2-positive cancer becomes resistant to the antibody-drug conjugate TDXD.

In the rare scenario of colorectal cancer with both HER2 amplification and a KRAS G12C mutation, US-based experts might prioritize KRAS-directed therapy. This preference is driven by durable data for KRAS inhibitors, even though choosing between targets is difficult without direct comparative studies.

In HER2-positive colorectal cancer, the choice of targeted therapy depends on RAS mutation status. The tucatinib/trastuzumab combination is effective only in RAS wild-type patients. In contrast, the antibody-drug conjugate trastuzumab deruxtecan (TDXD) shows efficacy regardless of whether a RAS mutation is present.

Contrary to concerns about cross-resistance between HER2 antibody-drug conjugates (ADCs), retrospective data shows TDM-1 remains effective after progression on TDXD. This suggests the different cytotoxic payloads are key, allowing for effective sequencing and challenging the assumption that progression on one ADC class member precludes using another.

As multiple effective Antibody-Drug Conjugates (ADCs) become available, the primary clinical challenge is no longer *if* they work, but *how* to use them best. Key unanswered questions involve optimal sequencing, dosing for treatment versus maintenance, and overall length of therapy, mirroring issues already seen in breast cancer.