Love is a powerful motivator within families and small groups. However, at a societal scale, it fails. A society that expects love to scale, like communism, inevitably resorts to force when that expectation is not met. Money, via markets, is the only scalable, non-coercive alternative.
Unlike physical technologies like the internet, money is a social technology. It's an invented system of trust that allows billions of strangers to cooperate and transact, forming the basis for complex civilization. It is the fifth element, propelling human progress.
Money is not just a medium of exchange; it is a core social technology that allows individuals to influence others' actions without resorting to violence. When monetary systems fail, society reverts to a state where physical power dictates outcomes.
Describing space exploration as a 'cash grab' isn't cynical; it's a recognition of fundamental human motivation. Money acts as 'proof of work,' incentivizing people to dedicate time and resources to difficult, long-term goals. Without a profit motive, ambitious endeavors like becoming a multi-planetary species would never attract the necessary capital and talent.
Socialism's top-down control ignores market incentives, leading to predictable failure (e.g., rent control causing building decay). When people protest these failures, proponents who believe they "know better" must resort to coercion and violence to silence dissent and maintain power, rather than admit their model is flawed.
Command economies inevitably rely on force. In a free society, disagreement is resolved through persuasion. In an authoritarian system where directives are absolute, dissent is ultimately met with force. Adopting a top-down economic model means accepting state-sanctioned violence as a necessary tool.
Society functions like a business with a CEO and an operator. It requires an evolutionary balance between compassion (the left's tendency) and personal responsibility (the right's tendency). One without the other becomes pathological, leading to either freeloading or a lack of cohesion. This tension is necessary for a healthy system.
Systems built on violence and coercion, such as authoritarian rule or forced taxation, are fundamentally unstable. They incentivize participants to constantly seek ways to escape, betray, or overthrow the system, creating a repeating cycle of conflict rather than sustainable social coherence.
Markets work because individuals value the same things differently, enabling transactions where both parties feel they have won. Understanding this principle of subjective value is the antidote to zero-sum thinking (like Marxism) which assumes value is objective and one person's gain must be another's loss.
Despite emotional rhetoric, human behavior is fundamentally driven by incentives. Even the most ardent socialists will act as capitalists when presented with direct personal gain, revealing that incentive-based economics is a core part of human nature.
Despite narratives of higher purpose, the bedrock of modern life is economic specialization. This system ensures survival and allows for hyper-specialization, which is why economic disruptions so easily unravel societal stability and lead to global conflict.