Current market bullishness is at levels seen only a few times in the past decade. Two of those instances led to corrections within three months. This euphoria, combined with low volatility and high leverage, makes the market vulnerable to even minor negative news.
Related Insights
In a rising market, the investors taking the most risk generate the highest returns, making them appear brilliant. However, this same aggression ensures they will be hurt the most when the market turns. This dynamic creates a powerful incentive to increase risk-taking, often just before a downturn.
During periods of intense market euphoria, investors with experience of past downturns are at a disadvantage. Their knowledge of how bubbles burst makes them cautious, causing them to underperform those who have only seen markets rebound, reinforcing a dangerous cycle of overconfidence.
Despite a massive tech stock run-up, key sentiment indicators and surveys of major asset allocators show caution, not the extreme bullishness seen in bubbles like the dot-com era. This suggests the market may not be at its absolute peak yet.
With the S&P 500's Price-to-Earnings ratio near 28 (almost double the historic average) and the Shiller P/E near 40, the stock market is priced for perfection. These high valuation levels have historically only been seen right before major market corrections, suggesting a very thin safety net for investors.
Veteran investor Jim Schaefer notes a recurring pattern before recessions: a massive, euphoric movement of capital into a specific area (e.g., telecom in 2001, mortgages in 2008). This over-investment inevitably creates systemic problems. Investors should be wary of any asset class currently experiencing such a large-scale influx.
The primary driver of market fluctuations is the dramatic shift in attitudes toward risk. In good times, investors become risk-tolerant and chase gains ('Risk is my friend'). In bad times, risk aversion dominates ('Get me out at any price'). This emotional pendulum causes security prices to fluctuate far more than their underlying intrinsic values.
Actively promoting extreme bullishness for a position you hold is counterproductive. It clouds judgment, ignores risk (like a potential double top), and invites a painful market correction as traders become emotionally attached and fail to sell when necessary.
A proprietary model tracking investor positioning shows a historic degree of credit bullishness, second-highest on a median basis. Such extremes typically precede adverse outcomes in financial markets, increasing the probability of a violent correction or choppy trading over the next one to three months.
Crossmark's Chief Market Strategist identifies investor complacency as her primary concern. The market's collective belief that earnings will continue to support upward momentum, despite underlying risks, creates a dangerous environment where investors are unprepared for shocks.
Despite the start of a new bull market, current 'frothy' conditions make a significant pullback likely. This should be viewed not as a threat, but as a normal occurrence and a buying opportunity. Near-term catalysts include escalating China trade tensions, stress in funding markets from quantitative tightening, and peaking earnings revisions.
