In an era of AI "slop," content that signals humanity—background noises, unpolished phone videos—converts better. Instagram's head even advocates for including imperfections like a dog barking to boost engagement, as it signals authenticity to viewers.

As AI tools enable marketers to produce more content, engagement is dropping for overly polished materials. Marketers are seeing better results with authentic, "lo-fi" content like screenshot testimonials and "day-in-the-life" videos that feel more human and trustworthy, even in formal B2B industries.

Highly produced video ads can feel jarring and inauthentic in a social feed. In contrast, user-generated style content that looks like it was filmed on a whim on an iPhone feels native to the platform. This authenticity leads to better performance, encapsulated by the DTC phrase 'the shakier, the better'.

Audiences crave authenticity, making highly polished videos feel unrelatable. Instead of investing in expensive gear, creators should invest in authentic storytelling, embracing a raw and imperfect style that builds more trust.

Instead of professionally designed case studies, use simple screenshots of customer testimonials in your marketing. This authentic, "lo-fi" format is perceived as more trustworthy and can significantly increase conversion rates on social media, emails, and websites, as shown by a head-to-head test.

Top creators like Mr. Beast relentlessly A/B test thumbnails and video intros to maximize views. AI video platforms now bring this data-driven experimentation to SMBs, allowing them to rapidly test variations of spokespeople, demographics, and creative elements to optimize ad performance.

Despite testing various ad formats, Spot & Tango's best-performing creative was a simple static photo of their product on an office shelf. This low-fi, authentic ad resonated more with customers because it mimicked user-generated content (UGC).

Overly polished video content in B2B can signal "advertisement" to users, causing them to disengage. Lower-fidelity, more authentic content often performs better because it feels more organic and native to social media feeds, focusing on the message rather than slick production.

In an era of highly produced brand content, raw, unpolished videos can feel more authentic and are more likely to stop the scroll. This "imperfect" quality is a strategic advantage, not a weakness, as it stands out against overly polished feeds.