Marketers often silo brand-building and sales-driving objectives, but they are intrinsically linked. If a creative fails to generate a short-term sales lift, it's a strong signal that it's also failing to build long-term brand equity. An ad that sells inherently delivers an equity benefit.

Over 60% of Super Bowl ads used celebrities, but most failed to deliver ROI. The few successes, like Ben Affleck for Dunkin', worked because the connection was sincere and pre-existing. Simply paying for fame without a genuine link is a waste of money.

Wix's CMO views expensive brand activities like Super Bowl ads through a dual lens. While building the brand is key, the investment must also generate a measurable spike in relevant user traffic to be considered successful. All marketing, regardless of type, must be treated as an investment.

The Super Bowl is most effective for brands facing a fundamental awareness problem—when the mass market simply doesn't know a product, feature, or solution exists. The platform's massive reach is ideal for closing this knowledge gap at scale.

Super Bowl advertising serves two distinct strategic purposes. For new or unknown companies, the goal is to achieve massive, instant brand awareness. For established, well-known brands like Raisin Bran, the ad serves to re-engage consumers and regain top-of-mind relevance in a crowded market.

While 68% of Super Bowl ads use celebrities to grab attention, this tactic can backfire. If the celebrity isn't a natural fit for the brand's story, consumers often remember the star but forget the product being advertised, leading to poor brand recall and wasted ad spend.

Zappi's methodology measures Super Bowl ads not just on likability, but on a "Sales Impact Score" benchmarked against a curated norm of the prior year's best-performing TV ads. This high bar of comparing against the "best of the best" separates merely entertaining ads from those that drive real business results.

Despite the high price, GaryVee argues no other platform, including Meta or TikTok, can guarantee 100 million viewers for a 30-second spot at that cost. The media buy itself is an unparalleled deal for attention. However, the ultimate success or failure of the investment hinges entirely on the quality and impact of the ad's creative.

Despite the hype, AI-focused Super Bowl ads underperformed because they used self-referential humor and assumed a level of consumer understanding that doesn't yet exist in a mass audience. This "inside baseball" approach failed to connect with broader viewers, limiting sales impact and proving ineffective for a mass-market event.