A psychologist agrees with Scott Galloway's critique of the therapy industry, highlighting that structural issues like poverty are key drivers of mental distress, and that not all therapy is accessible or ethical. This counters the simplistic social media backlash against his views.

Related Insights

With three-quarters of mental health providers being women, the field may have a significant blind spot regarding male issues. This gender imbalance can make it difficult for men to feel seen and heard, creating a structural barrier to effective treatment that goes beyond social stigma and pushes them towards toxic online communities.

When terms like "setting boundaries" escape the clinic and scale on social media, they lose their clinical meaning. This "therapy speak" becomes a cultural currency, used by those who suffer least to frame minor disagreements as trauma, weaponize emotional reactions, and promote a culture of fragility rather than genuine healing.

The narrative that personal problems require therapy pathologizes what are often systemic economic issues. You cannot "therapy your way out of material precarity." Structural solutions like higher wages, affordable housing, and a stronger social safety net are often more effective mental health policies than individual introspection.

The history of depression treatment shows a recurring pattern: a new therapy (from psychoanalysis to Prozac) is overhyped as a cure-all, only for disappointment to set in as its limitations and side effects become clear. This cycle of idealization then devaluation prevents a realistic assessment of a treatment's specific uses and downsides.

Contrary to the colonial-era view that depression was a "Western" disease, community-based psychotherapy models are now flowing from low-income countries to high-income ones. For example, a successful Zimbabwean program using grandmothers as therapists to address social issues like poverty and abuse is now inspiring similar community healthcare initiatives in the US.

Connective labor can be sustaining, not draining. Burnout occurs when the "social architecture" lacks support systems like "sounding boards" for practitioners to process their work. The problem isn't the emotional work itself, but the conditions under which it's performed.

Contrary to popular belief, the U.S. has more mental health practitioners per capita than medical doctors. The crisis stems from a systemic distribution failure: therapists are concentrated in urban areas, many don't accept insurance due to low reimbursement rates, and high costs make access impossible for rural and low-income communities.

America's mental health crisis is largely driven by economic precarity. Systemic solutions like a higher minimum wage, affordable housing, and universal healthcare would be more effective at improving population well-being than an individualistic focus on therapy, which often treats symptoms rather than the root cause of financial stress.

Relying solely on talk therapy for a physiological problem can be counterproductive. When a patient makes no progress despite their efforts, they can develop learned helplessness and self-blame, concluding they are a "failure" and worsening their condition.

Social inequalities are a major risk factor for depression, making it a political problem. However, this is not a reason to deny medical treatment. Like other diseases of inequality such as AIDS or COVID-19, individuals need medical help now and cannot wait for underlying societal issues to be resolved.