Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Many subscribers sign up for a lead magnet but forget to open the email. Set up an automation to send a gentle reminder four hours later to anyone who hasn't opened the initial email. This simple tactic can recapture a significant percentage of otherwise lost engagement without annoying users.

Related Insights

PDF lead magnets are often downloaded and forgotten. Instead, break that content into a 5-10 day automated email sequence. This drip-feeds information in digestible chunks, dramatically improving content retention, engagement, and the opportunity to build a relationship with new subscribers.

Set up an automation that watches your inbox. When someone replies to a specific email with a keyword like "template," the system automatically replies within the same email thread to deliver the lead magnet, bypassing complex ESP sequences.

To win back inactive subscribers, send a short sequence (2-3 emails) with direct, urgent subject lines like 'Should I stop emailing you?'. The email body should be simple: acknowledge their absence and provide one clear button to click to stay subscribed. This cuts through the noise they've been ignoring.

Don't rely solely on automated sequences. Sending occasional, manually written, one-off emails to the same audience—without pausing the automation—can dramatically improve results. This "over the top" approach breaks the pattern and re-engages users who have become accustomed to the automated flow, waking them up.

Be cautious with the "resend to unopens" feature. Tests show it often fails to meaningfully increase overall open rates. Worse, it can annoy subscribers and lead to spam complaints, especially since open-tracking pixels are not foolproof and may misidentify readers as non-openers.

Sending all your automated emails at a predictable time, like 9 AM, trains your audience to ignore them, turning them into "wallpaper." To break this pattern and make automations feel less robotic, vary the send times significantly, even using unconventional hours like 8 PM.

Instead of relying solely on automated sequences, send sporadic, manually written emails to the same audience without pausing the automation. This unexpected, human touch can "wake up" subscribers, leading to significantly higher engagement and business results compared to pure automation.

An automated email course is a superior lead magnet because it delivers value daily over a set period. This consistency trains new subscribers to anticipate and open your emails, establishing a strong engagement habit from the very beginning of your relationship.

For subscribers who don't open an email, a simple and effective tactic is to resend the exact same content. The only change is tweaking the subject line and pre-header to capture their attention. Since they never saw the original content, it's still new to them and requires minimal effort to redeploy.

Marketer Jay Schwedelson argues that non-openers are distracted, not disinterested. He advises resending the same email within 48 hours but with a new, aggressive subject line that creates urgency (e.g., 'Yikes, you scrolled past this'). This gives the message a second chance to cut through the inbox noise.