The true cost of returns is a 25% hit to top-line revenue, comprising 17% in refunds and 8% in related operational expenses. This financial drain is staggering when compared to the average 12% operating margin for top public e-commerce brands, highlighting returns management as a critical area for profitability.
Related Insights
With AI enabling precise control over media spend, key performance indicators are changing. Brands now move beyond simple Return on Ad Spend (ROAS) to more sophisticated metrics like incremental ROAS and contribution margin, reflecting a new emphasis on profitable growth rather than just volume.
The primary driver for returns is no longer defective items. Instead, factors like inflation and impulsive 'buy now, pay later' habits are increasing 'regret-driven' returns due to uncertainty and expectation mismatch. This psychological shift means the return experience must now solve for customer anxiety, not just logistical or product issues.
Rising return rates aren't just an operational issue but a reflection of deeper consumer trends. According to data from SEEL, economic uncertainty and normalized 'try before you buy' behavior have caused a 30% year-over-year surge in returns, making the post-purchase experience a critical factor in the initial buying decision.
As return volumes rise, brands that make the process effortless and predictable will earn loyalty that can't be bought. This frictionless experience during a period of high customer anxiety builds a durable competitive moat. Every return also generates compounding data advantages for future forecasting and merchandising, further widening the gap.
Escape the trap of chasing top-line revenue. Instead, make contribution margin (revenue minus COGS, ad spend, and discounts) your primary success metric. This provides a truer picture of business health and aligns the entire organization around profitable, sustainable growth rather than vanity metrics.
Use gross margin as a quick filter for a new business idea. A low margin often indicates a lack of differentiation or true value-add. If a customer won't pay a premium, it suggests they have alternatives and you're competing in a commoditized space, facing inevitable margin compression.
Merchants can effectively offload clearance inventory by making 'final sale' items returnable. This strategy removes consumer anxiety and significantly lifts conversion. Counter-intuitively, this policy change does not lead to a meaningful increase in actual returns, turning a traditionally high-risk purchase for consumers into a confident sale for brands.
To fund crucial investments in wages, prices, and e-commerce, Walmart's leadership, with board support, intentionally reduced its operating income from over 6% to just over 4%. This shareholder-funded investment was a deliberate, multi-year strategy to future-proof the business.
In low-margin sectors like grocery, chasing sales volume is unsustainable. The true value of retail media lies in improving profitability by driving guaranteed incremental sales and avoiding wasted ad spend on existing customer behavior, directly impacting the bottom line.
Starting with drop shipping proved the concept but offered unsustainable margins. The pivot to in-house apparel manufacturing unlocked significantly higher profits (from a £2 margin to £15). This allowed them to reinvest capital back into the business, fueling actual growth.
