Historically, citizens accepted exceptionally high tax rates when they felt a deep sense of patriotism and belief in their country's greatness. Eroding this national narrative makes unpopular but necessary fiscal policies nearly impossible to implement.

Related Insights

Reframe patriotism not as blind nationalism, but as acknowledging the immense, unearned privilege of one's birthplace and its opportunities. This creates a sense of gratitude and responsibility—a debt owed to the society, systems, and people whose sacrifices created that environment of opportunity.

The lack of a unified national narrative creates profound societal division. America is fractured by two irreconcilable stories: one of colonialist oppression and another of unprecedented prosperity, making a shared identity and collective action impossible.

Just as a parent uses discipline to keep a child on the right path, leaders must use unpopular but necessary fiscal measures (like balancing the budget) to ensure a country's long-term health, even if it's not what the populace wants in the short term.

A key reason for past legislative success was that leaders shared a common identity forged in military service. Reinstating mandatory national service could create 'connective tissue' among diverse young people, fostering a unified identity as citizens first and foremost, before individual identity groups.

When a country is successful for too long, its citizens forget the difficult and often violent actions required to achieve that prosperity. This ignorance leads to guilt, a weakened national identity, and an inability to make tough decisions for self-preservation.

Historically, countries crossing a 130% debt-to-GDP ratio experience revolution or collapse. As the U.S. approaches this threshold (currently 122%), its massive debt forces zero-sum political fights over a shrinking pie, directly fueling the social unrest and polarization seen today.

Tax policy is a reflection of societal values. By taxing capital gains at a lower rate than ordinary income, the U.S. tax code inherently suggests that wealth generated from existing money (assets, stocks) is more valuable or 'noble' than wealth generated from work and labor.

A critical political challenge is convincing citizens to accept necessary domestic budget cuts while simultaneously funding international alliances. The message fails when people already feel financially strained, making fiscal responsibility and global power projection seem mutually exclusive and out of touch.

Instead of attacking wealth, a more effective progressive strategy is to champion aggressive, 'hardcore' capitalism while implementing high, Reagan-era tax rates on the resulting gains. This framework uses the engine of capitalism to generate wealth, which is then taxed heavily to fund public investments in infrastructure and education, creating a virtuous cycle.

The true danger isn't partisan bickering but the collapse of shared cultural institutions like family, faith, and community. These provided a common identity and purpose that held the nation together, and their erosion leaves a void that politics cannot fill, removing the nation's "center of gravity."