Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Brown separates remote access, exported chips, and indigenously produced chips. Remote access can be cut off at any moment, exported chips offer leverage at export, but indigenous production offers little leverage. That is why China's own lithography capacity matters for long-term power.

Related Insights

Analyst Chris Miller argues China's core challenge is manufacturing, as it lacks the advanced lithography tools monopolized by ASML. The US and Taiwan are projected to produce 30 times more quality-adjusted AI chips, a gap unlikely to close soon.

Brown says CSET reports show China making inroads in etch, deposition, and CMP, but it still has zero meaningful lithography market share. He expects lithography to be the hardest and last tool China indigenizes, making current lithography stockpiles a useful long-term bound.

Selling semiconductor equipment allows China to create hundreds of billions in downstream value. In contrast, selling API access to US models is a higher-margin strategy that keeps core value creation within the American ecosystem, extracting more revenue per unit of capability provided.

Brown says if China keeps importing lithography at its 2024-25 pace and shifts a larger share to AI, the curve bends upward. In that AI-push scenario, China could reach near parity or parity with US chipmaking in about ten years.

China will likely struggle to indigenously manufacture commercial DUV immersion lithography tools until the mid-2030s, long after domesticating deposition or etch tools. Because only Japan and the Netherlands produce them, lithography remains the West's most durable geopolitical lever.

A zero-tolerance policy on selling advanced AI chips to China might be strategically shortsighted. Allowing some sales could build a degree of dependence within China's ecosystem. This dependence then becomes a powerful point of leverage that the U.S. could exploit in a future crisis, a weapon it wouldn't have if China were forced into total self-sufficiency from the start.

Contrary to advocating for a full embargo, Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang argues that selling advanced chips to China is strategically advantageous for the US. His thesis is that creating technological dependency on American hardware is a more powerful long-term lever than allowing China to become self-sufficient with domestic champions.

China's semiconductor strategy is not merely to reverse-engineer Western technology like ASML's. It's a well-funded "primacy race" to develop novel, AI-driven lithography systems. This approach aims to create superior, not just parallel, manufacturing capabilities to gain global economic leverage.

The effectiveness of US export controls on advanced AI chips stems from a deep technological gap. According to China's own projections, it won't be able to domestically produce chips as powerful as those the US is restricting until 2028, creating a significant and lasting strategic advantage for democracies.

Rather than slowing China down, US measures like chip export controls backfired. They effectively incentivized China to accelerate its own modernization and develop an independent, and equally effective, technology stack, diminishing long-term US leverage.

Remote compute access gives US more leverage than Chinese fabs | RiffOn