To preserve authenticity, treat the creative brief as the destination (the goal, the key message), but let the creator 'drive.' They know their audience and platform best. Overly prescriptive briefs with scripts or restrictive guardrails kill the authenticity that makes influencer marketing effective, turning the content into a generic ad.

The most effective influencer marketing now involves scaling back on rigid creative briefs. By providing general guidelines instead of a script, brands empower creators to produce more authentic content that resonates better with their audience and builds more trust.

Treating creator partnerships as a media buy by providing a script yields poor results. HubSpot found that collaborating deeply—letting creators write scripts and co-create offers—converts better. This approach trusts the creator's expertise with their own audience and leads to better performance.

Forcing brand messaging on an influencer leads to inauthentic content that fails to resonate. A better approach is to educate them on your product and collaborate on an angle that aligns with their established voice and topics. Authenticity drives distribution and engagement, making the partnership more effective than a boilerplate promotion.

The most common mistake brands make is hiring creators for their authentic connection with an audience, only to then provide a rigid corporate script. This practice undermines the creator's unique voice, leads to ineffective content, and proves the brand fundamentally misunderstands the medium.

To achieve genuine endorsements, brands must trust creators. Instead of providing rigid scripts, give them key message points and the freedom to tell the story in their own voice. This creative liberty results in more authentic advertising that resonates with the creator's audience.

Brands struggling with the bandwidth to manage creators should shift their mindset. Viewing creators as human partners, rather than fungible "media units" or "affiliate links," is crucial. This requires both technology that empowers them and dedicated support to build authentic relationships.

Digitas CEO Amy Lanzi avoids the term "influencer" because it implies a transactional ad buy that audiences reject. Instead, she advocates treating "creators" as a "brand's best friend." They should be integrated into the marketing org to co-create authentically and use their community to feed the product development pipeline.

Vector's marketing lead found success by giving influencers high-level messaging points but allowing them to create content in their own voice. The only request was to review the post 24 hours in advance to ensure product accuracy.