Shipt identified markups, fees, and tips as a key driver of churn. Since tips and some fees were unavoidable, they strategically focused on eliminating markups—the one component of the cost structure they could directly control—to create a powerful competitive advantage.
After 9 months of stagnation, Deliver implemented two key changes based on customer feedback: a "Prime-like" badge to surface the value of fast shipping earlier in the funnel, and a flat-rate pricing model for predictability. These two changes combined created an immediate inflection point, leading to explosive growth.
In the competitive food delivery market, service fees frustrate both customers and restaurants. By eliminating this key fee, similar to Robinhood's disruption of trading commissions, DoorDash could become the preferred platform. Shifting to a subscription model like Costco would foster immense goodwill and lock in loyalty.
To win as a low-cost service provider, every decision must be optimized for operational efficiency from day one, like offshoring talent and using heavy automation. Simply lowering prices because a premium model failed is a losing strategy, as the underlying cost structure is fundamentally different.
Deliver's growth stagnated until they shifted from complex, variable fees to a simple flat rate. This treated pricing not as a billing model but as a product feature that solved the customer's core need for financial predictability, which became their primary growth catalyst.
High-margin software businesses operate on 'easy mode,' which can mask inefficiencies. To build a truly durable company, founders should study discount retailers like Costco or Aldi. These businesses thrive on razor-thin margins by mastering cost reduction, operational simplicity, and value delivery—lessons directly applicable to building efficient software companies.
By removing markups for premium members, Shipt's traditional Customer Lifetime Value (CLV) calculation became obsolete for this segment. This forced the company to fundamentally rethink how it defines and measures the value of its most engaged customers beyond per-order revenue.
Rather than a universal price adjustment that would upend its business model, Shipt tested its "no markups" initiative within its Target Circle 360 membership. This limited financial exposure, targeted high-value customers, and created a powerful incentive for membership renewal and engagement.
Counter-intuitively, for price-sensitive markets, decreasing average order value (AOV) is a key growth lever. A lower entry price point unlocks a larger segment of the population, increasing transaction frequency, building habits, and ultimately driving higher lifetime value.
Shure prices its service at $100/month vs. the industry's ~$600. This isn't just to compete with incumbents like Deel, but to serve a massive pool of smaller companies for whom traditional EORs were prohibitively expensive, thereby expanding the total addressable market.
After getting executive buy-in for a major pricing change, Shipt's biggest challenge was marketing. They had to simplify a complex message about eliminating markups for a specific member segment, make it compelling, and navigate legal requirements, which required extensive message testing and collaboration.