AI video creative is no longer theoretical. E-commerce company Ridge reports that it is running full-blown AI-generated videos that are "winners in the ad account." These assets now command up to a third of the company's total ad spend, proving their real-world performance.

AI can now analyze video ads frame by frame, identifying the most compelling moments and justifying its choices with sophisticated creative principles like color theory and narrative juxtaposition. This allows for deep qualitative analysis of creative effectiveness at scale, surpassing simple A/B testing.

According to Higgsfield AI, a new market is emerging where Fortune 500 brands are bypassing large ad agencies and hiring small (10-30 person) AI-native firms to create social media commercials. This demonstrates a strategic shift towards agile, specialized partners for AI-driven creative production.

AI in creative doesn't have to dilute a brand. Coca-Cola's successful holiday ad used AI, but its high brand recall (83%) was driven by focusing on iconic assets like Santa. The AI execution was effective because it was largely invisible, proving the creative idea still drives the ad, not the tech.

Studies show people often prefer AI-generated art based on quality alone, but their preference flips to the human-created version once they know the source. This reveals a deep-seated bias for human effort, posing a significant "Catch-22" for marketers who risk losing audience appreciation if their AI usage is discovered.

While media coverage suggests public disdain for AI-generated ads, Coca-Cola's consumer data shows high approval scores. This highlights a critical gap between the sentiment of a threatened media industry and actual consumer behavior, suggesting audiences care more about the final product than its AI origin.

As AI makes creating complex visuals trivial, audiences will become skeptical of content like surrealist photos or polished B-roll. They will increasingly assume it is AI-generated rather than the result of human skill, leading to lower trust and engagement.

While AI video tools can generate visually interesting ads cheaply and capture views, they currently lack the authentic creative spark needed for true brand building. Their value lies in quick, low-cost content, making them a performance marketing tool rather than an asset for creating a lasting, memorable brand identity.

The goal for advertising in AI shouldn't just be to avoid disruption. The aim is to create ads so valuable and helpful that users would prefer the experience *with* the ads. This shifts the focus from simple relevance to actively enhancing the user's task or solving their immediate problem.