Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

To avoid "innovation theater," front-load the financial viability assessment to the very first stage gate. By asking about margins and P&L impact upfront, companies can kill 80% of unworkable, buzzword-driven projects before investing significant time and emotional energy.

Related Insights

The goal of early validation is not to confirm your genius, but to risk being proven wrong before committing resources. Negative feedback is a valuable outcome that prevents building the wrong product. It often reveals that the real opportunity is "a degree to the left" of the original idea.

Before committing resources to a proof-of-concept (POC), build a preliminary ROI case. If the potential return isn't substantial enough for the customer to reallocate budget or personnel, the deal is unlikely to close. This step prevents wasting both your and your customer's time on unwinnable evaluations.

Innovation fails when treated as a sporadic event. Walmart established a formal, stage-gated pipeline (intake, evaluation, POC, MVP) that operates outside normal planning cycles. This systematic process provides a clear path for ideas to be validated and funded, increasing their success rate.

True innovation isn't about brainstorming endless ideas, but about methodically de-risking a concept in the correct order. The crucial first step is achieving problem clarity. Teams often fail by jumping to solutions before they have sufficiently reduced uncertainty about the core problem.

Spend significant time debating and mapping out a project's feasibility with a trusted group before starting to build. This internal stress-test is crucial for de-risking massive undertakings by ensuring there's a clear, plausible path to the end goal.

Jacobs's team uses the acronym WOTWOM—Waste Of Time, Waste Of Money—as a rapid check on new ideas. Any suggestion can be challenged with this label if it doesn't clearly contribute to organic revenue growth or margin expansion. This simple tool creates a culture focused on high-leverage activities.

Aim for "good enough" financial estimates to differentiate multi-million dollar opportunities from thousand-dollar ones. This high-level sorting is more valuable and efficient than creating detailed, yet still speculative, forecasts for every idea.

Instead of asking for general feedback, Decagon's founder systematized ideation by pressing potential customers on exactly how much they would pay, who approves the budget, and how they would justify ROI. This filters out weak ideas and provides strong commercial signals.

Validate market demand by securing payment from customers before investing significant resources in building anything. This applies to software, hardware, and services, completely eliminating the risk of creating something nobody wants to buy.

A simple but powerful framework for any product initiative requires answering four questions: 1) What is it? 2) Why does it matter (financially)? 3) How much will it cost (including hiring and ops)? 4) When do I get it? This forces teams to think through the full business impact, not just the user value.