Unlike other generations, Gen X turned 20 amidst mixed signals—optimism from the Cold War's end but cynicism from recession. This lack of a single, powerful 'zeitgeist' resulted in scattered ambition, not a concentrated cluster of leaders, thus serving as a control group for the theory.

Unlike established systems with clear rules (like Christianity), the modern left operates on "vague vibes" of ideological purity. This lack of a self-regulation mechanism creates a constant pressure to prove loyalty through extremism. As standards escalate, anyone who could provide a moderating influence is purged, leading to an endless cycle of radicalization.

The erosion of trusted, centralized news sources by social media creates an information vacuum. This forces people into a state of 'conspiracy brain,' where they either distrust all information or create flawed connections between unverified data points.

Extreme online subcultures, however small, function as 'existence proofs.' They demonstrate what is possible when a generation is severed from historical context and tradition, connected only by algorithms and pornography. They are a warning sign of the potential outcomes of our current digital environment.

Humans have a "God-shaped hole"—a fundamental need for shared values and community, historically filled by religion. As formal religion wanes, the internet facilitates the creation of new tribes. These online groups provide belonging but are often pathological and based on grievance.

Unlimited access to information can turn political engagement into a hobby of encyclopedic knowledge. Individuals focus on memorizing countless ideologies, much like collecting Pokémon, which replaces deep understanding and practical application with superficial, rote learning.

Analyzing the memetic activity of niche online groups, like teenage eco-anarchists in 2018, serves as an "early detection" system for forecasting larger political narratives and cultural shifts, as their fringe concerns often scale to mass audiences.

Extremist figures are not organic phenomena but are actively amplified by social media algorithms that prioritize incendiary content for engagement. This process elevates noxious ideas far beyond their natural reach, effectively manufacturing influence for profit and normalizing extremism.

A deep distrust of the bipartisan "neoliberal consensus" has made many young people receptive to any counter-narrative, whether from the left or right. This creates a powerful anti-establishment bloc that finds common ground in opposing the status quo, explaining the crossover appeal of populist figures.