It's possible to have strong GDP growth without a corresponding drop in unemployment. Goldman Sachs' forecast squares this by pointing to accelerating productivity growth, meaning the economy can expand its output without necessarily hiring more workers.
Related Insights
The economy presents a confusing picture with acceptable GDP growth but virtually no job creation. This disconnect creates anxiety because for most people, job security, not GDP, is the primary measure of economic health. This leads to a feeling of being 'schizophrenic' about the economy's true state.
Contrary to the dominant job-loss narrative, a Vanguard study reveals that occupations highly exposed to AI are experiencing faster growth in both jobs and wages. This suggests AI is currently acting as a productivity tool that increases the value of labor rather than replacing it.
Despite AI's narrative as a labor-replacement technology, NVIDIA's booming chip sales are occurring alongside strong job growth. This suggests that, for now, AI is acting as a productivity tool that is creating economic expansion and new roles faster than it is causing net job destruction.
The combination of solid GDP growth and weaker job creation is not necessarily a warning sign, but a structural shift. With productivity growth rebounding to its 2% historical average and labor supply constrained by lower immigration, the economy can grow robustly without adding as many jobs as in the past.
Despite strong productivity numbers alongside flat job growth, economists believe it is too early for AI to be the primary driver. The gains are more likely attributable to businesses becoming more dynamic and achieving better labor-market matches following the pandemic disruptions, rather than a widespread technological revolution.
Contrary to fears of mass unemployment, AI will create massive deflationary pressure, making goods and services cheaper. This will allow people to support their lifestyles by working fewer hours and retiring earlier, leading to a labor shortage as new AI-driven industries simultaneously create new jobs.
While fears of job loss from automation dominate headlines, Vanguard's Joe Davis argues the real drag on economic growth is a *lack* of automation. The service sector, representing 80% of jobs, has seen little productivity improvement since the internet boom, leading to overall economic stagnation.
Rather than causing mass unemployment, AI's productivity gains will lead to shorter work weeks and more leisure time. This shift creates new economic opportunities and jobs in sectors that cater to this expanded free time, like live events and hospitality, thus rebalancing the labor market.
The labor market faces a dual threat. Weak demand, linked to tariffs and deglobalization, has already pushed job growth to zero. As AI adoption accelerates productivity, it could further suppress labor demand, potentially tipping the economy into a state of net job decline.
Despite strong GDP and corporate profits, productivity gains are eliminating lower-skilled jobs. BlackRock's Rick Reeder warns this is creating a social problem where aggregate consumption looks healthy, but a segment of the population is being left behind, a dynamic he calls a "travesty."
