The bidding war for Warner Bros. Discovery between Netflix and Paramount is complex because the offers aren't apples-to-apples. Netflix only wants the studio and streaming assets, leaving behind valuable linear channels like CNN and HGTV. The board's decision hinges on assigning a separate value to this discarded "network business."
Related Insights
Warner Bros. Discovery highlighted a key flaw in Paramount's offer: the $40 billion equity commitment is backed by an opaque, revocable trust, not a direct, unconditional guarantee from the Ellison family. This lack of transparent financial certainty makes a competing deal far more secure and appealing to shareholders.
Paramount's bid is for the entire Warner Bros. Discovery entity, including its cable networks. In contrast, Netflix's offer targets only the studio and HBO assets. This structural difference, along with attached debt and spin-offs, makes a simple price-per-share comparison between the two deals misleading.
The bidding war isn't between equals. Paramount, a smaller and weaker legacy media company, sees the acquisition as a necessity for future relevance. For the much stronger Netflix, it's an opportunistic play to cement its market leadership.
While HBO has brand recognition, the most valuable asset in the Warner Bros. deal is its television production studio. Its deep catalog and role as a key content supplier for all streaming services makes it strategically invaluable.
Unlike the infamous AOL-Time Warner merger where an overvalued tech stock bought a solid media asset, Netflix, a genuinely valuable company, is considering buying a legacy media library at a potentially inflated price. This signals a strategic shift from bubble-currency acquisitions to potentially overpriced consolidation by established tech players.
Beyond price, Paramount's offer for Warner Bros. is handicapped by strict covenants limiting WBD's operational flexibility during the potential 18-month closing period. WBD's board fears these restrictions would be costly, making Netflix's more flexible offer more attractive.
The intense bidding war for Warner Bros. Discovery is driven by unique strategic goals. Paramount seeks subscriber scale for survival, Netflix wants premium IP and sports rights, and Comcast primarily needs modern franchises like Harry Potter to fuel its profitable theme park business.
In the Warner Bros. acquisition, the value of seemingly dormant IP like Looney Tunes is meticulously calculated. Bankers assign specific multi-million dollar figures to assets like 'Foghorn Leghorn,' demonstrating that a deep, monetizable character library is a primary driver of these mega-deals, not just current blockbuster franchises.
While the obvious targets for Netflix are Warner's famous IP like Batman, acquiring CNN would be a game-changer. It would provide a proven, global, 24/7 live content stream, accelerating Netflix's strategic shift from on-demand video to a constant live-event platform.
In the bidding war for Warner Bros., Netflix is targeting the valuable studio IP, while Paramount critically needs the declining-but-profitable linear cable assets like CNN. This is because Paramount lacks the free cash flow of Netflix and requires the cable networks' earnings simply to finance the highly leveraged deal.
