Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Federal rules cap total aid at the cost of attendance, so a new outside scholarship can force the school to cut something. Nicole Lapin says schools choose what to reduce: loans and work-study or their own grants. If grants are cut first, the scholarship displaces aid and the family bill does not fall.

Related Insights

The federal student loan program is the primary driver of skyrocketing tuition. Because it provides indiscriminate funding, it removes any incentive for universities to control costs or improve quality. Ending the program would reintroduce market forces, forcing prices down and aligning degrees with job market realities.

The aid formula uses income from two years before college, so the tax year starting in January of a student's sophomore year of high school is the one that counts. Nicole Lapin warns that big stock sales or bonuses that year can count up to 47 cents per dollar against aid.

The US Dept. of Education is proposing an accountability test: if a degree program's graduates don't earn more than comparable workers without that degree, the program could lose access to federal student loans. This directly links federal funding to a graduate's financial ROI.

Private colleges gave first-year students an average 57% discount last year; at the University of Chicago, a $104,000 sticker price becomes about $25,000 for the average aid recipient. Nicole Lapin says every federal-aid school must post a net price calculator, so run it before ruling a school out.

To fix the student debt crisis, universities should be financially on the hook for the first portion of any loan default (e.g., $20,000). This "first loss" position would compel them to underwrite the economic viability of their own degrees, creating a powerful market check against pushing students into overpriced and low-value programs.

Parent PLUS loans used to cover the full cost of attendance; as of July 1, they are capped at $20,000 a year and $65,000 total per kid. Nicole Lapin says that safety valve is now smaller, so a $40,000 annual gap needs savings, private loans, or a cheaper school.

Blanket student loan forgiveness fails to address the root cause: skyrocketing tuition fueled by easy credit. A better solution is to force universities to have skin in the game by making them financially liable for a percentage of defaulted loans, which would incentivize responsible lending and curb price inflation.

A section of the tax code lets employers pay up to $5,250 a year toward an employee's student loans tax-free, and the law made that permanent. Nicole Lapin says graduating students should treat loan repayment like a signing bonus and ask for it during job-offer negotiations.

The FAFSA counts money in a child's name at up to 20%, while a parent-owned 529 is assessed around 5%; $10,000 can cut aid by $2,000 versus about $560. Nicole Lapin says if aid matters, keep college money in a 529 you own or retirement accounts, not a custodial account.

The debate over college's worth should be framed as a bargain, not a simple "good vs. bad" decision. The most critical factor is the amount of debt incurred. A full-ride scholarship has minimal downside, whereas a debt-funded degree for a non-essential career can be a significant financial trap.