Instead of focusing on vanity metrics, Chanel Clark measures success by asking what void TMC fills. Her North Star is the value members would lose if it disappeared—connections, peer support, and industry collaboration. This frames the community's purpose around its indispensable, qualitative impact.
The owner of Royal Air shifted her mindset from seeking measurable ROI for their mascot and community events. Instead, success is tracked through "quiet notices": overhearing positive comments, seeing branded buttons on kids' backpacks, and being recognized at events. This highlights the cumulative, qualitative impact of brand-building.
To accelerate progress, distill your company's entire mission into a single, quantifiable "North Star Metric." This focuses every department—from engineering to marketing—on one shared objective, eliminating conflicting priorities and aligning all efforts towards a common definition of success.
When leaders are stuck defining their organization's mission, this question forces a shift from generic goals like survival to tangible impact. It clarifies the unique value provided to customers and society, revealing a more motivating and authentic purpose beyond simply 'staying in business.'
Simply stating a goal, like "increase sales by 15%," is insufficient for autonomous teams. Leaders must also articulate the "anti-vision"—the negative outcomes to avoid, such as eroding customer experience. This rich context provides clearer guardrails and a more nuanced understanding of the mission.
While marketing content attracts members to the Exit 5 community, the real value and retention driver is the personal connections formed between members. The speaker shares a story of two women who met through the community and became real-life friends, demonstrating the product's ultimate purpose.
Most people have social (fun) and collaborative (work) communities, but lack a 'formative' one. This distinct type of community is dedicated to the process of 'becoming together,' where members ask questions about personal growth ('are you becoming a better you?') rather than task completion ('did you get it done?').
The metric for a successful community has shifted from high activity ("noise") to high trust. Members no longer want to sift through hundreds of discussions. They want a smaller, curated space where they can trust the expertise and intentions of the other people in the room.
Product teams focus on technical metrics like scalability, but customer-facing teams see success differently: it's when a client says they "couldn't run their business" without the product. The goal is to merge these two definitions by translating technical achievements into tangible customer outcomes.
Shift the team's language and metrics away from output. Instead of celebrating a deployed API, measure and report on what that API enabled for other teams and the business. This directly connects platform work to tangible results and impact.
Shift from viewing a community as a side project to treating it as a core product. This means implementing a product owner, roadmap, features, feedback loops, and key metrics like NPS to ensure it's continuously improving and not just a creator's side project.