We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.
Gina Smilich says economic rules are clearly not like physics. Every few years, a model that was supposed to work absolutely starts to break down, forcing a reappraisal. She argues that remembering economics is a philosophy at its root matters when those models often fail.
Understanding economics requires hands-on experience, like running a business with personal financial risk. Purely philosophical knowledge leads to unworkable ideas because it lacks a grasp of real-world cause and effect, where a bad decision could cost you your house.
The financial industry suffers from 'physics envy'—a desire for predictable laws like those in hard sciences. This leads to complex models that give an illusion of certainty in what is actually a complex, adaptive system, where such precision is impossible and often misleading.
Neoclassical economics operates like a religion, ignoring empirical data that contradicts its core tenets. The crucial role of bank-created credit in causing financial crises is dismissed because accepting it would unravel their entire equilibrium-based model. This willful ignorance is why they consistently fail to predict crashes.
Economic theory is built on the flawed premise of a rational, economically-motivated individual. Financial historian Russell Napier argues this ignores psychology, sociology, and politics, making financial history a better guide for investors. The theory's mathematical edifice crumbles without this core assumption.
Work by Kahneman and Tversky shows how human psychology deviates from rational choice theory. However, the deeper issue isn't our failure to adhere to the model, but that the model itself is a terrible guide for making meaningful decisions. The goal should not be to become a better calculator.
Post-WWII, economists pursued mathematical rigor by modeling human behavior as perfectly rational (i.e., 'maximizing'). This was a convenient simplification for building models, not an accurate depiction of how people actually make decisions, which are often messy and imperfect.
To truly understand complex systems like the economy, one should focus on the 'physics' of cause and effect. This approach helps build a robust mental model, making it clear where your understanding breaks down and what specific questions you need to research.
Milton Friedman's 'as if' defense of rational models—that people act 'as if' they are experts—is flawed. Predicting the behavior of an average golfer by modeling Tiger Woods is bound to fail. Models must account for the behavior of regular people, not just theoretical, hyper-rational experts.
Politicians often propose policies based on ideals without respecting economic realities, like aerodynamics in race car design. Ignoring factors like capital mobility or supply and demand leads to predictable system failure. Effective policy must be grounded in these "physics" rather than wishful thinking.
A core methodological flaw in neoclassical economics is its deductive approach: it builds models based on axioms (e.g., perfect rationality) that don't reflect reality. In contrast, institutional economics is inductive, constructing theory from evidence-based observation. This explains why neoclassical models failed to predict the 2008 crisis and why their proponents refused to change them afterward.