IPA database analysis reveals a stark truth: budget size is the single most important marketing decision. Effectiveness is overwhelmingly determined by spend (90%), with creative and media efficiency accounting for only 10%. The biggest lever you can pull is the budget itself.

Related Insights

A low Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) might seem successful, but it could be hiding inefficient creative. Optimizing creative strategy could dramatically lower CAC further (e.g., from $39 to $16), unlocking greater profitability and scale, especially as you increase ad spend.

A study of 110 CMOs reveals a direct correlation between growth and marketing spend. High-growth firms (over 6% YoY revenue growth) invest substantially more—about 35%—in their marketing budgets, challenging the common practice of cutting marketing during economic uncertainty.

Stop planning creative and media buys simultaneously. Instead, post creative organically first. Then, exclusively allocate media spend to amplify the content that has already demonstrated strong consumer engagement, forcing creative to be effective on its own merit before receiving paid support.

If your creative assets aren't culturally relevant, you're forced to overspend on media to achieve impact. Truly resonant content generates organic reach and makes paid amplification more efficient, a key argument for CFOs on the value of creative investment.

Data shows that adding brand marketing to a performance-driven engine can increase median ROI by 90%. The persistent tension between brand and performance stems from short-termism and the allure of easily measured clicks, creating a false dichotomy between two essential functions.

In the current "interest media" era, social platforms act as a free testing ground. Post content organically, identify what performs best with the algorithm, and only then invest media dollars to amplify those proven winners, eliminating expensive guesswork.

With Meta's Andromeda algorithm automating audience targeting, the primary reason for poor ad performance is no longer incorrect targeting settings. Wasted money is now almost exclusively a result of insufficient or non-diverse creative, making creative strategy the most critical component of a successful campaign.

In mature ad markets, creative quality is the biggest variable for success, not media spend. High-performing companies now shift budget away from platforms like Meta and Google and reinvest it into producing more content. This superior creative makes the remaining, smaller media spend far more effective.

Research from Les Binet shows that budget scale is far more critical for market share gain than campaign ROI. While ROI is important, it only explains 11% of the variance in incremental profit. The industry's focus on efficiency and narrow targeting is hindering significant growth potential.

Marketers often equate effectiveness with ad ROI, but communications typically drive only 10% of sales. The other 90% is influenced by levers like pricing, distribution, and product performance. True marketing effectiveness requires a holistic view across all these business areas, not just advertising.