Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Greg Roche says engagement surveys usually return anonymous aggregates, so items about speaking up or volunteering can confuse introversion with disengagement. A quiet engineering-heavy company may score low without revealing whether people are willing to expend discretionary effort. He warns against treating engaged as extroverted and disengaged as introverted.

Related Insights

Employees often provide "safe" answers on engagement surveys to avoid being labeled as problematic. This strategic behavior means the data reflects what they're willing to share, not the actual day-to-day problems, rendering the survey results unreliable for diagnosing root causes.

Greg Roche says managers should directly ask quiet attendees what they are thinking during meetings. A simple “what questions do you have?” gives introverts a low-pressure entry point, reveals their processing, and keeps the loudest voice from dominating. He calls this a concrete way leaders can engage half their workforce.

Greg Roche defines engagement as willingness to expend discretionary effort, not visible activity. Quiet employees may deliver results without talking in meetings, then get misread as checked out. He warns leaders to judge output and effort rather than equate extroverted behavior with being engaged, and notes introverts may be especially poor at self-promotion.

A company with 78% engagement scores was hemorrhaging high-potential talent. Exit interviews revealed the cause: employees were engaged in their work but were exhausted from trying to "fit in." This shows that engagement and belonging are not the same and must be measured independently.

Standard engagement surveys fail because employees fear answering direct questions about job satisfaction or retention honestly. A more effective approach is to use a proxy question like, "How seen and heard do you feel by your immediate supervisor?" which provides a safer space for truthful responses.

Greg Roche says introverts often assume results speak for themselves, but he warns nobody else will publicize their work. He coaches them to share accomplishments in authentic, one-on-one ways and tells leaders to create visibility for quiet contributors, because promotions depend on being known as well as delivering.

UPS achieved its best-ever employee engagement scores just months before a company-wide strike. This highlights a critical survey flaw: if you don't ask about the topics most important to the workforce, you can get a completely misleading picture of organizational health.

In meetings, three people often do 70% of the talking. This dominance, coupled with a cultural bias that equates quick, loud speech with intelligence, leads companies to over-promote charismatic extroverts while overlooking valuable ideas from quieter team members.

Companies get trapped in a futile cycle of launching surveys, receiving detailed reports, and running workshops, yet no behavioral change occurs. This is because the act of measuring culture is confused with the act of actually improving it, leading to wasted resources and recurring problems.

Traditional surveys act as confirmation tools, only measuring pre-selected topics. They are structurally incapable of discovering the unknown environmental factors, like process frictions or scheduling conflicts, that are the true root causes of employee disengagement.