Mehta argues liberal nationalism relied on globalization's promise of non-zero-sum mutual prosperity across nations. As the United States and China openly compete for singular geopolitical primacy, national self-preservation inevitably forces states to abandon international public goods, open cooperative agreements, and underlying liberal commitments.
Pratap Bhanu Mehta observed that student demonstrators in Delhi broke the government's standard playbook by mocking power rather than debating policy. Previous movements against Modi tackled specific laws, but playful contempt left officials without an obvious script to counter fearless youth who converted diffuse city locations into protest sites.
Pratap Bhanu Mehta notes that in deeply unequal societies like India, standardized exams and elections serve as the sole avenues perceived as fair and meritocratic. When paper leaks and testing agencies fail, lower-middle-class students without family wealth or kinship networks see their only escape from poverty abruptly pulled away.
Mehta explains that India's Election Commission introduced centrally controlled software that flagged names for deletion despite verification by local neighborhood officials. Bypassing doorstep certifications by schoolteachers in favor of distant algorithmic notices severely eroded public confidence and disenfranchised millions ahead of critical state elections.
Mehta points out that populist leaders such as Donald Trump and Narendra Modi convince citizens that institutional checks and balances cause governmental paralysis. By framing legal constraints, free press, and courts as self-serving elite vetoes, executives present centralized unchecked authority as the only path to national greatness.
Mehta highlights that while India clocked 7 percent headline growth, college graduate unemployment hovers around 25 percent. The current youth demonstrations are unique because they include children of middle-class parents who gained from 1990s market reforms but now face disappearing rungs on the upward ladder.
Mehta contends middle powers no longer pick sides between Washington and Beijing because both superpowers have turned rogue in weaponizing technology, trade, and sanctions. Instead, intermediate nations seek bilateral trade deals and supply chain networks designed solely to insulate their economies from unpredictable American and Chinese coercion.
Mehta argues Modi avoids firing his Chief Election Commissioner because granting public accountability breaks internal government discipline. Autocrats maintain loyal civil services by assuring officials they answer only upward to the regime, whereas succumbing to civic protest signals subordinates that following harsh executive directives carries personal career risk.
