An offer that seems too good to be true will be met with skepticism and ignored, even if it's genuine. To make an extreme offer believable, you must provide a compelling reason, such as a "going out of business" sale, to justify the discount and overcome prospect distrust.
Free offers attract high volume but often low quality. Counter this by adding strategic friction—like multi-step forms or forced video consumption—to weed out uncommitted prospects. The goal is finding the sweet spot that maximizes qualified leads without losing high-value but lazy prospects.
Split tests reveal that leads from free offers convert at the same rate and ticket size as those from paid offers. The primary difference is that free offers dramatically lower lead acquisition costs (by 5x or more), making them more profitable. The "freebie seeker" stereotype is largely a myth.
Marketers fail with premium offers because they don't adjust pricing to match higher lead costs. If a premium lead costs 5-10x more than a free lead, the product price must be 5-10x higher to maintain profitability. Free and premium are entirely different, non-interchangeable acquisition models.