/
© 2026 RiffOn. All rights reserved.

Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

  1. The Marketing Millennials
  2. When NOT to Market Your Brand, with Paul Reiss, Founder of Protein Pints
When NOT to Market Your Brand, with Paul Reiss, Founder of Protein Pints

When NOT to Market Your Brand, with Paul Reiss, Founder of Protein Pints

The Marketing Millennials · Jul 15, 2026

Protein Pints founder Paul Reiss explains how controlled marketing and product obsession scaled his brand from 1 to 15,000 stores.

Protein Pints Capitalized on the DIY 'Ninja Creamy' Trend by Offering a Convenient Alternative

The founder saw millions making protein ice cream at home with Ninja Creamy machines but identified the inconvenience (prep time, ingredients) as a key pain point. His CPG brand offers a ready-to-eat solution to a problem that a popular appliance created.

When NOT to Market Your Brand, with Paul Reiss, Founder of Protein Pints thumbnail

When NOT to Market Your Brand, with Paul Reiss, Founder of Protein Pints

The Marketing Millennials·6 days ago

Early-Stage CPG Brands Should Intentionally Limit Marketing to Avoid Premature Virality

The founder feared going viral before having national distribution would alert competitors and waste impressions on customers who couldn't buy. They practiced "controlled marketing" to match brand awareness with their retail footprint, preventing lost sales and copycats.

When NOT to Market Your Brand, with Paul Reiss, Founder of Protein Pints thumbnail

When NOT to Market Your Brand, with Paul Reiss, Founder of Protein Pints

The Marketing Millennials·6 days ago

Protein Pints Founders Got Jobs at an Ice Cream Shop to Learn Product Formulation

Lacking food science expertise, the founders applied for jobs at a local from-scratch ice cream shop to learn the craft. This unconventional, hands-on approach to R&D not only provided crucial knowledge but also led to a key mentorship with the shop's owner.

When NOT to Market Your Brand, with Paul Reiss, Founder of Protein Pints thumbnail

When NOT to Market Your Brand, with Paul Reiss, Founder of Protein Pints

The Marketing Millennials·6 days ago

A Local Pitch Event Booth Led Directly to Protein Pints' First Major Retail Deal

Instead of traditional sales outreach, the founders secured their first major retailer, Meijer, after a representative saw the customer excitement at their booth during a local pitch competition. This demonstrates how grassroots events can generate serendipitous, high-impact distribution opportunities.

When NOT to Market Your Brand, with Paul Reiss, Founder of Protein Pints thumbnail

When NOT to Market Your Brand, with Paul Reiss, Founder of Protein Pints

The Marketing Millennials·6 days ago

Protein Pints Guaranteed Early Retail Success by Focusing All Marketing on One Store

With their product in just one store, the founders concentrated all marketing efforts locally through events at gyms and markets. This hyper-focused strategy drove foot traffic directly to that single location, ensured they sold out weekly, and proved product velocity to their retail partner.

When NOT to Market Your Brand, with Paul Reiss, Founder of Protein Pints thumbnail

When NOT to Market Your Brand, with Paul Reiss, Founder of Protein Pints

The Marketing Millennials·6 days ago

The Founder's Daily Habit of Eating His Own Product Fuels His Resilience to Criticism

To overcome doubt, the founder relies on his profound belief in the product, reinforced by his habit of eating two pints of his ice cream every day for four years. This constant personal use serves as a daily reminder of his mission and the value he provides customers.

When NOT to Market Your Brand, with Paul Reiss, Founder of Protein Pints thumbnail

When NOT to Market Your Brand, with Paul Reiss, Founder of Protein Pints

The Marketing Millennials·6 days ago

CPG Brands Win by Communicating Their Value Proposition in Under Half a Second On-Shelf

In an age of information overload, the most effective marketing is extreme simplicity. A brand's ability to instantly communicate its core value on a crowded retail shelf is the key differentiator for winning consumer attention. Achieving this simplicity is a complex strategic task.

When NOT to Market Your Brand, with Paul Reiss, Founder of Protein Pints thumbnail

When NOT to Market Your Brand, with Paul Reiss, Founder of Protein Pints

The Marketing Millennials·6 days ago