The 5% default rate in private credit, compared to 3% in syndicated loans, is a function of its target market: smaller companies. Just as the Russell 2000 is more volatile than the Dow Jones, smaller businesses are inherently riskier. Applying leverage to a more volatile asset pool naturally results in more defaults.

Years of low interest rates encouraged risk-taking, resulting in a large pool of low-rated loans (B3/B-). Now, sustained higher rates are stressing these weak capital structures, creating a boom in distressed debt opportunities even as the broader economy performs well.

Default rates are not uniform. High-yield bonds are low due to a 2020 "cleansing." Leveraged loans show elevated defaults due to higher rates. Private credit defaults are masked but may be as high as 6%, indicated by "bad PIK" amendments, suggesting hidden stress.

Historically, lower-quality credit cycles involved periods of high returns followed by giving all the gains back in a downturn. Post-GFC, the absence of a sustained recession has allowed private credit to outperform high-quality bonds by 7% annually without the typical "give it all back" phase, masking latent risks.

Recent stress in credit card and auto loan markets is concentrated in loans originated in 2021-2023 when stimulus and looser standards prevailed. Lenders have since tightened, and newer loan portfolios are performing better, suggesting the problem is not spreading systemically.

Despite headlines blaming private credit for failures like First Brands, the vast majority (over 95%) of the exposure lies with banks and in the liquid credit markets. This narrative overlooks the structural advantages and deeper diligence inherent in private deals.

Unlike syndicated loans where non-payment is a clear default, private credit has a "third state" where lenders accept PIK interest on underperforming loans. When this "bad PIK" is correctly categorized as a default, the sector's true default rate is significantly higher, around 5% versus 3% for syndicated loans.

Problem loans from the 2021-22 era will take years to resolve due to private credit's tendency to "kick the can." This will lead to a prolonged period of underwhelming mid-single-digit returns, even in a strong economy, rather than a dramatic bust.

Recent credit failures and frauds are not 'systemic' risks that threaten the entire financial system's structure. Instead, they are 'systematic'—a regularly recurring behavioral phenomenon. Good times predictably lead to imprudent lending, creating clusters of defaults. The problem is human behavior, not a fundamental flaw in the market itself.