Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Brian Gertzner warns that positioning an agency around AI tools is a temporary gimmick that will vanish rapidly. Because clients already assume agencies use AI and simply expect responsible handling, agencies rushing after tech buzzwords risk moving fast without knowing their destination or building enduring authority.

Related Insights

As AI democratizes information, simply having knowledge is no longer a differentiator. The real expertise lies in its application. Use AI to quickly become an industry expert by identifying key trends, but reserve human effort for interpreting and applying that information for clients.

While the tech world obsesses over AI, positioning a product as 'AI-first' can be a liability in mainstream markets. Many non-tech users are skeptical or actively hostile towards AI, making it a poor marketing message. Focus on the problem solved, not the underlying technology which can create backlash.

Agencies can no longer rely on a single, lasting competitive advantage. AI commoditizes services on a rapid cycle. The only viable strategy is to operate on the leading edge, constantly seeking the next temporary advantage, with the understanding that it will likely be obsolete within 12-18 months.

Clients are overwhelmed by their chaotic AI adoption. Agencies can transition from commoditized service providers to strategic leaders by offering to systematically install and manage AI within a client's marketing operations, turning a market threat into a high-value, high-margin service.

Agencies building their entire value proposition around AI are chasing a short-lived trend. Much like the "social media agencies" of the past, this differentiator is evaporating as clients now expect AI to be a standard tool used responsibly. The real value lies in strategic application, not the tool itself.

While clients may use AI tools like ChatGPT to check agency work, it won't eliminate the need for expert service. Instead, AI raises the bar. Clients will expect more efficiency and better results for their money, and will crave a deeper, consultative human partnership to navigate the new complexity.

With nearly every public B2B company now featuring AI, the novelty has worn off. 'AI washing' by adding a simple co-pilot is no longer a differentiator. To succeed, companies must use AI to create genuinely disruptive products that solve problems in ways that were previously impossible.

Many businesses attempt to hack together AI tools and discover it creates chaotic, time-consuming noise instead of efficiency. Agencies that install structured, strategic AI workflows into a company's marketing operations gain trusted leadership roles by organizing that chaos.

Aggressively adopting AI without guardrails leads to low-quality "slop." AI should be a component that serves a broader strategy, not the entire strategy. It is a powerful tool for informing and consulting, but human judgment remains critical to curating quality outcomes and preventing an increase in remedial work.

Now that generative AI is accessible to all, claiming "we have AI" is table stakes. The real competitive advantage lies in clearly articulating what the AI *does* for the user to create a differentiated product experience and value proposition. The key question is always, "So what?"