Just as newspapers ceded their audience to Google for traffic, retailers are being tempted to let AI chatbots handle customer interactions. This trade sacrifices brand identity and direct customer relationships for short-term volume—a historically catastrophic move that leads to commoditization by an aggregator.
Related Insights
The dominance of Google Ads is threatened by AI-powered chatbots, which are poised to disrupt search-based advertising just as Google disrupted the Yellow Pages. Businesses reliant on this channel must pivot their strategies immediately.
As users delegate purchasing and research to AI agents, brands will lose control over the buyer's journey. Websites must be optimized for agent-to-agent communication, not just human interaction, as AI assistants will find, compare, and even purchase products autonomously.
The idea of a truly "open web" was a brief historical moment. Powerful, proprietary "organizing layers" like search engines and app stores inevitably emerge to centralize ecosystems and capture value. Today's AI chatbots are simply the newest form of these organizing layers.
AI agents shop based on optimized specs, not human heuristics like brand trust. This shift to "agentic commerce" could neutralize the power of major brands like Walmart and Amazon, and eliminate the interpersonal relationships that sustain local, small businesses.
As both consumers and companies adopt personal AI agents, many transactions will occur directly between these bots without human involvement. This disintermediates the customer from the company, fundamentally changing the nature of CX and requiring new ways to measure success and reinforce brand value in a fully automated interaction.
While AI shopping agents promise to protect consumer privacy by abstracting away direct retailer relationships, this is a false dawn. Power will likely centralize with the major tech companies providing these agents, not empower individual users with decentralized control. The battle for "owning the customer" simply moves to a new layer.
As consumers use AI assistants (e.g., Alexa) to find services, the platform will choose the provider. If customers don't ask for your business by name, you become a commodity. Building a strong brand is the only way to ensure customers request you directly.
AI will fragment the customer journey across countless platforms, moving purchases away from brand-owned websites. Retailers must build systems to manage inventory and product information across this decentralized landscape, not just focus on perfecting their own site experience.
While large retailers will adopt Google's in-app AI checkout, smaller D2C brands face a tough choice. Participating means ceding control of branding and the customer relationship, but sitting out risks becoming invisible as shopper behavior shifts to AI-native purchasing, making it difficult to catch up later.
OpenAI's promise to keep ads separate mirrors Google's initial approach. However, historical precedent shows that ad platforms tend to gradually integrate ads more deeply into the user experience, eventually making them nearly indistinguishable from organic content. This "boiling the frog" strategy erodes user trust over time.
