After discontinuing their print magazine, Campaigns & Elections received angry emails. Upon checking, they found the most vocal critics were "industry dinosaurs" who had already canceled their paid subscriptions. This highlights the importance of filtering feedback from non-paying, legacy users before taking action.
Related Insights
Your happiest, biggest customers are satisfied because your product already works for them. The most valuable insights for innovation and growth come from understanding your non-customers—the people not buying from you. Their unmet needs represent your largest untapped opportunities.
To combat a high 44% churn rate, the company implemented a simple feedback loop. They surveyed every user who canceled to ask why and what features they wanted. Each month, the team reviewed the feedback and built the most popular requests, steadily improving the product and retention.
After radically changing her newsletter's tone, Amy Porterfield faced negative feedback and unsubscribes. She reframes this as a positive 'shedding season,' a necessary process to filter out misaligned followers and attract an audience that connects with her authentic self. She even used a negative comment as a subject line, which performed well.
Reacting to churn is a losing battle. The secret is to identify the characteristics of your best customers—those who stay and are happy to pay. Then, channel all marketing and sales resources into acquiring more customers that fit this 'stayer' profile, effectively designing churn out of your funnel.
Systematically call every customer who has churned, not to win them back, but to thank them and understand why they left. This provides invaluable, unfiltered market research. By the 19th call, you'll have identified core product or service issues that data alone cannot reveal.
A sudden increase in unsubscribes after a marketing change isn't necessarily a failure. It often means you've successfully grabbed the attention of disengaged subscribers who then self-select out because the content is no longer relevant, which is a healthy outcome for your list.
Most marketing avoids negativity, but proactively addressing your product's flaws or top churn reasons is a powerful strategy. It disarms skeptical buyers who are used to perfect marketing narratives. This transparency builds trust and attracts best-fit customers who won't be surprised by your product's limitations.
Churn is a lagging indicator. It's the delayed consequence of past product roadmap decisions and a failure to stay aligned with customer needs. By the time a customer leaves, the strategic misstep has already occurred, making churn analysis a post-mortem on old strategy, not a real-time event.
When customers cancel due to 'budget cuts,' it's rarely just about the money. It signals your product wasn't perceived as indispensable. If they saw sufficient value, they would fight to keep the budget for it. This feedback is a direct critique of your value proposition, not an external, uncontrollable factor.
When the Coppell Chronicle's founder considered adding ads, paying subscribers responded negatively, with some even offering a higher subscription fee to keep it ad-free. This reveals that for a niche audience, an ad-free experience is a core product feature they are willing to pay a premium for.