Unlike older search algorithms gamed by keywords, AI has the potential to identify and surface genuinely useful and trustworthy content. This shift could benefit expert-driven media and creators by rewarding depth and authority over optimization hacks, leading to a 'return to trust.'
Related Insights
LLMs frequently cite sources that rank poorly on traditional search engines (page 3 and beyond). They are better at identifying canonically correct and authoritative information, regardless of backlinks or domain authority. This gives high-quality, niche content a better chance to be surfaced than ever before.
LLMs can actually benefit sites with deep, authoritative content, even if it's not ranked #1 on Google. AI models prioritize surfacing the best answer, regardless of traditional rank, potentially increasing traffic for subject matter experts.
Google's Robbie Stein explains that because AI models, including Google's own, use web searches to gather real-time information, creating trusted, authoritative content remains the most effective strategy for being featured in AI-generated answers.
Shopify's Harley Finkelstein argues agentic commerce will make SEO obsolete. Instead of brands gaming search rankings, AI will recommend products based on merit and a user's personal context history. This shift could level the playing field, allowing smaller, high-quality brands to be discovered more easily.
As AI devalues simple clicks, marketing focus must shift to building a strong brand that algorithms recognize as authoritative. High-quality, well-structured owned content (like blogs and reports) becomes more critical for discoverability than traditional performance marketing tactics.
As users increasingly turn to AI for answers, clicks to websites are dropping. Brands must now focus on Answer Engine Optimization (AEO), structuring their site's data and content to be easily scraped and presented by AI, not just ranking for keywords in traditional search.
Generative AI changes brand discovery from a budget-driven game to one based on relevance, credibility, and usefulness. This levels the playing field, allowing smaller, more agile brands to compete with larger incumbents who traditionally relied on massive ad budgets.
With 80-90% of AI-powered searches resulting in no clicks, traditional SEO is dying. The new key metric is "share of voice"—how often your brand is cited in AI-generated answers. This requires a fundamental strategy shift to Answer Engine Optimization (AEO), focusing on becoming an authoritative source for LLMs rather than just driving website traffic.
As AI and LLMs become central to information discovery, they will rely on high-quality, well-written sources. This creates a "revenge of the English major" scenario where brands with strong storytelling and quality content (e.g., from PR) will gain an edge over those just focused on paid ranking, as human quality becomes a key input for AI.
In the era of zero-click AI search, driving website traffic is less important than being cited as an authority within LLM responses. Marketers must now optimize content to appear in places like Reddit and G2, as these are the sources AI models use to formulate answers and build credibility.
