We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.
Gina Smilich says F.Y. Edgeworth and the marginalists applied utility theory to economics, writing models that claimed to describe the world. They wanted economics to look like physics, and Alfred Marshall's textbook later dropped 'political' from the field's name as it became an academic pursuit.
Joe Weisenthal compares Edgeworth to later Koch-funded economics fiction, but Gina Smilich says that comparison misses her context. Writing just after Adam Smith and the French Revolution, Edgeworth was translating a new way of thinking for ordinary readers and citizens, not selling a fixed ideology.
The post-war dominance of mathematical economics was not a natural evolution. It was heavily influenced by US Department of Defense funding, which employed mathematicians and engineers to model weapon systems. This approach was then applied to the economy, reframing it as an optimized machine populated by rational "cyborgs," divorced from social reality.
Emad Mostaque proposes that the math behind generative AI can describe economic systems. In this framework, Adam Smith's theories map to "gradient flows" (scarcity), Marx's to "circular flows" (compounding intelligence), and Hayek's to "harmonic flows" (structural rules).
Gina Smilich says economic rules are clearly not like physics. Every few years, a model that was supposed to work absolutely starts to break down, forcing a reappraisal. She argues that remembering economics is a philosophy at its root matters when those models often fail.
Gina Smilich says Edgeworth reviewed a French translation of Bentham and translated it back into English, simplifying it for ordinary readers. Some academic research suggests the utilitarian ideas her nephew F.Y. Edgeworth later developed probably originated with her, though the evidence is not completely definitive.
Post-WWII, economists pursued mathematical rigor by modeling human behavior as perfectly rational (i.e., 'maximizing'). This was a convenient simplification for building models, not an accurate depiction of how people actually make decisions, which are often messy and imperfect.
The original study of economics was "political economy," which understood the economy as inseparable from politics, law, and history. The late 19th-century rise of neoclassical thought deliberately separated these fields, treating the economy as a natural, pre-political system, akin to a law of physics like gravity.
Gina Smilich says Edgeworth took Smith's abstract ideas and applied them to Irish estate management. Castle Rackrent discusses where to set rents, how to pay wages, how to incentivize workers and how to avoid squandering resources in a way that runs the estate into the ground.
To truly understand complex systems like the economy, one should focus on the 'physics' of cause and effect. This approach helps build a robust mental model, making it clear where your understanding breaks down and what specific questions you need to research.
For a period, a perverse norm developed in economics where the 'better' academic model was one whose theoretical agents were smarter and more rational. This created a competition to move further away from actual human behavior, valuing mathematical elegance and theoretical intelligence over practical, real-world applicability.