Get your free personalized podcast brief
We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.
Content performance on Instagram follows a "reverse bell curve." Reels with minimal editing ("yapping" style) or those with highly cinematic, professional editing perform best. Content with mediocre, in-between levels of editing struggles to gain traction, suggesting creators should commit to one extreme or the other.
Related Insights
The middle ground of social content is disappearing. To succeed, creators must either produce hyper-professional, cinematic-quality work or embrace completely raw, authentic, unedited content. Attempting to compete with gimmicky, mid-level edits is a losing strategy as it fails to stand out.
A simple change of scenery can dramatically impact performance. Internal tests show that reels filmed outside perform, on average, 34% better in views and engagement than identical reels with the same scripts filmed inside. Committing to filming in more dynamic locations is a powerful growth lever.
Instagram's algorithm is expected to evolve, placing more weight on watch time over simple interactions. This change will favor the rise of longer, unscripted, "FaceTime-style" storytelling content that has proven successful on TikTok, signaling a move away from short, highly-edited Reels.
The old strategy of creating long, infographic-style pins is obsolete. Pinterest now prioritizes authentic, scroll-stopping videos similar to Instagram Reels. Even poorly designed but powerful videos that grab attention outperform highly polished, traditional pins, signaling a major shift in creative strategy.
A study of 10,000 Reels found that videos featuring speech (direct-to-camera or voiceover) have a significantly higher engagement rate and increase average watch time by nearly 25%. This data contradicts the common strategy of relying solely on trending audio for Reels.
Data reveals Instagram Reels now achieve double the reach (30%) and engagement of traditional photo or carousel posts (13-14%). With Instagram's head confirming the app is being redesigned around Reels and DMs, marketers should shift all focus to video and deprioritize static image content.
The more time spent scripting, refining, and editing a post, the less authentic it becomes and the worse it typically performs. Higher-performing content often results from reducing the time between the initial idea and hitting 'publish.'
In an era of highly produced brand content, raw, unpolished videos can feel more authentic and are more likely to stop the scroll. This "imperfect" quality is a strategic advantage, not a weakness, as it stands out against overly polished feeds.
According to Instagram's head, Adam Mosseri, creators should stop over-editing videos. Content featuring imperfections like background noise, stumbles, or hiccups is seen as more authentic and is achieving greater organic reach. This "proof of life" approach resonates more with users than perfectly polished, AI-like content.
Data shows a split in performance between post types. Instagram's algorithm favors Reels for reach, showing them to more people. However, audiences are more likely to engage with Carousels, which see higher engagement rates (6.9% median for Carousels vs. 3.3% for Reels). A balanced strategy should include both formats.