While neoadjuvant immunotherapy shows astounding success in MSI-high rectal cancer, the primary difficulty for clinicians lies in accurately assessing complete response via endoscopy and MRI, and managing unique complications like mucin pools or stenosis, rather than simply administering the treatment.

In the Keynote 522 trial for early-stage TNBC, adding pembrolizumab to chemotherapy resulted in only a modest improvement in pathological complete response (pCR). Surprisingly, this small initial gain translated into much more robust and significant long-term improvements in event-free and overall survival.

The RUBY trial surprisingly revealed that patients with p53-mutated tumors, a subset of the generally less responsive pMMR group, derive significant benefit from adding immunotherapy to chemotherapy, challenging previous assumptions about this molecular subtype.

While the ATOMIC trial established FOLFOX plus atezolizumab as a new standard for adjuvant therapy in MSI-high colon cancer, its design lacked an immunotherapy-only arm. This leaves a critical, unanswered question about the actual contribution and necessity of the chemotherapy component.

Experts indicate that Tumor Mutational Burden (TMB) is losing relevance for guiding immunotherapy in GI cancers. The TMB cutoff of 10 is not considered reliable across tumor types, and clinicians still prefer combination chemo-immunotherapy even in TMB-high patients, unless MMR deficiency is also present.

Retrospective data suggests patients with MSI-high rectal cancer might not just respond poorly to standard neoadjuvant chemoradiation (TNT), but their disease could actually progress. This makes immunotherapy a potentially safer and more effective first-line neoadjuvant choice, not just an alternative.

For MSI-high patients responding to immunotherapy, a lingering mass on a CT scan may not be active cancer. A negative ctDNA test can help confirm that the visible lesion is likely just scar tissue, potentially averting unnecessary surgery.

Data from trials like CheckMate 816 shows that achieving a Pathologic Complete Response (PCR) after neoadjuvant chemo-immunotherapy is a powerful early surrogate endpoint. Patients with PCR demonstrate markedly improved overall and event-free survival.

The KEYNOTE-177 trial allowed patients on the chemotherapy arm to cross over to pembrolizumab upon progression. Despite this, pembrolizumab showed a significant survival advantage, implying the actual benefit of using immunotherapy first-line is even greater than what the data shows.