Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

John Lear says commercial real estate had strong, quiet growth for 15 months, but cap rates have climbed about 50 basis points in the last month. Deals in the pipeline for three months are now repricing, creating distress and delaying closings. That makes CRE more vulnerable to higher-for-longer rates.

Related Insights

Despite massive private market dry powder, deal volume has slowed because sellers and their bankers are stuck on pricing from the low-interest-rate era. Buyers, facing higher financing costs, cannot make the numbers work, creating a market stalemate or "quagmire."

John Lear cites MBA origination data showing office lending up 47% year over year, but he stresses it is coming from near-zero volumes. He argues fully leased Class A office can offer 200 basis points over tight multifamily and industrial loans, making the risk worth pricing again.

While rising interest rates caused all CRE asset classes to become more correlated in their price movements, the magnitude of those movements varies historically. Some segments like institutional office fell 50% peak-to-trough, while industrial properties saw no decline at all, creating the widest price dispersion ever recorded.

Unlike past cycles triggered by economic fundamentals like job losses, the recent CRE downturn was driven by capital markets (i.e., interest rate hikes). Because underlying property performance remained strong, lenders could confidently "extend and pretend," providing stability and preventing a catastrophic crash and broader economic contagion.

After development projects suffered from cost overruns and cap rate expansion, large investors have pivoted. They now favor core and core-plus strategies, de-risking their portfolios by targeting assets where 50-70% of the total return comes from immediate cash flow, not future appreciation.

The market is focused on potential rate cuts, but the true opportunity for credit investors is in the numerous corporate and real estate capital structures designed for a zero-rate world. These are unsustainable at today's normalized rates, meaning the full impact of past hikes is still unfolding.

While fears of a commercial property crisis peaked in early 2023, the worst-case scenarios failed to materialize. Key indicators are now showing a clear recovery, with transaction volumes, prices, and debt origination all rising. This suggests a disconnect between lingering negative sentiment and improving on-the-ground fundamentals.

In a low-rate environment, developers profited from financial arbitrage. With higher rates, that's impossible. Profitability now depends on creating a genuinely desirable product with strong tenant demand, shifting the focus from spreadsheets to quality and talent.

The CRE market successfully navigated a capital markets-driven downturn. It remains vulnerable to a stagflationary scenario where high inflation keeps interest rates elevated while weak growth erodes fundamentals (e.g., employment). This dual pressure would be disastrous, undermining the stability that has so far prevented a crash.

While rising rates caused a violent valuation drop in commercial real estate (CRE), they also choked off new development. This lack of new supply—a primary driver of winners and losers in CRE—creates a strong fundamental tailwind for 2026-2028, making the sector more stable than recent volatility suggests.