Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Investment team members often conflate raising potential risks with having weak conviction, which damages intellectual honesty. Highlighting portfolio hazards and deal flaws is essential due diligence, and teams should actively encourage uncovering warts before committing capital.

Related Insights

To ensure robust decision-making, Eclipse requires that if a partner feels strongly against a potential investment, they must join the deal team alongside the champions. This forces a direct confrontation of the risks and ensures that by the time an investment is made, all major concerns have been addressed.

To ensure rigorous debate, assign an external 'challenger' to investment committees. This person's sole job is to identify potential failures (a 'premortem') and challenge the deal team's assumptions, structurally embedding disagreement into the process and overcoming the natural tendency to avoid conflict.

Progress uses an "orange flag" system to identify diligence issues that, while not immediate deal-breakers, are serious enough to warrant a discussion with the CEO and CFO. This allows for an early decision to walk away before expending significant resources.

In an effective investment team, the responsibility of junior members is to "attack" and "challenge" the lead portfolio manager's ideas. This structure leverages cognitive diversity to cancel out individual biases and leads to more robust decisions than seeking consensus.

The absence of significant flaws or negative perspectives on a deal is a red flag, suggesting something was missed in diligence. True exceptionality is what carries a great investment, not a lack of risk. If everyone agrees it's a great deal, you're likely too late or wrong.

To avoid becoming emotionally invested in a deal, it's crucial to institutionalize a "devil's advocate" role. Proactively searching for reasons *not* to do the deal ensures a sober, realistic assessment. The final decision is a calculated risk based on incomplete (e.g., 80%) information.

During diligence, an investable founder is transparent about current risks (e.g., a major customer account is in jeopardy) and presents a mitigation plan. This candor is more valuable and trust-building to an investor than a founder who projects a flawless, risk-free business.

Assigning a team of uninvolved colleagues to act as a "red team" forces a contrarian perspective. Their job is to find flaws and articulate why a deal should not be done, which de-risks investments by identifying weaknesses before capital is committed and sharpens the whole team's thinking.

CPP Investments' CEO warns that spending more time on a flawed deal doesn't improve it; you just risk convincing yourself it's viable. The most critical skill is recognizing a bad investment early and having the discipline to walk away, rather than trying to structure your way out of its fundamental flaws.

When evaluating a deal sponsor, favor those who are reflective over those who are purely sales-oriented. The best sponsors demonstrate transparency and thoughtfulness by proactively highlighting a deal's risks on the first slide, rather than trying to hide weaknesses to secure a management fee.

Surface Critical Investment Risks Freely Without Fearing It Signals a Lack of Conviction | RiffOn