The absence of key data releases like non-farm payrolls during a government shutdown reduces market-moving catalysts. This artificially lowers volatility, creating a stable environment conducive to running carry trades and maintaining existing positions like dollar shorts, contrary to expectations of increased uncertainty.
Related Insights
The dollar initially weathered the U.S. government shutdown. However, with the FAA now actively canceling flights, the negative GDP impact is becoming more tangible and less likely to be recovered quickly, increasing downside risk for the currency.
The success of the current EM FX carry trade isn't driven by wide interest rate differentials, which are not historically high. Instead, the strategy is performing well because a resilient global growth environment is suppressing currency volatility, making it profitable to hold high-yielding currencies against low-yielders.
Despite a packed calendar of central bank decisions and key data releases, broad FX volatility is hovering near five-year lows. This suggests investors are underpricing potential market moves, and current options pricing for events like U.S. payrolls may be insufficient to cover a significant data surprise.
A historical review places 2026 in the second-lowest decile for central bank rate activity (hikes/cuts). This data strongly suggests a contained FX volatility environment, as significant vol spikes historically occur only during periods of extremely high or low central bank intervention.
Shutdowns halt the release of key data like jobs reports and inflation figures. This obstructs the Federal Reserve's ability to make informed interest rate decisions, creating market uncertainty. It also delays Social Security COLA calculations, impacting millions of retirees who rely on that data.
While mass firings of federal workers may not significantly alter overall payroll statistics, their real impact is a potential shock to consumer and business confidence. This second-order effect on sentiment is a key underappreciated risk that the market has not fully priced into the US dollar.
During episodes of US government dysfunction, such as shutdowns, the dollar tends to weaken against alternative reserve assets. The concurrent strength in gold and Bitcoin provides tangible market validation for the 'dollar debasement' thesis, suggesting investors are actively seeking havens from perceived fiscal mismanagement.
A bearish Canadian dollar (CAD) position can act as a superior proxy for a bearish US dollar (USD) view. It provides insulation against temporary USD rallies (as USD/CAD rises) and offers better carry efficiency due to the Bank of Canada's dovish stance, making it a lower-beta, potentially higher-return strategy.
The US dollar's rally has a natural ceiling because the government shutdown is withholding crucial growth and labor market data. Without this data, markets lack the conviction to push the dollar significantly higher, making the trend self-limiting.
The US dollar's recent slide is not just due to a pro-risk environment. Markets are also pricing in the government reopening, which involves running down the Treasury General Account (TGA). This action is expected to inject significant liquidity into money markets, placing short-term downward pressure on the dollar.