Using a BCMA bispecific antibody first can exhaust a patient's T-cells or cause tumors to lose the BCMA target, rendering a subsequent BCMA-targeted CAR-T therapy ineffective. The optimal sequence is CAR-T first, which preserves T-cell function and BCMA expression, leaving bispecifics as a viable later-line option.
Related Insights
In the Cartitude 1 trial, the strongest predictor of long-term remission with Siltacel was a lower burden of disease (measured by bone marrow percentage and soluble BCMA levels), rather than the number of prior treatments. This implies using CAR-T therapy earlier in the disease course is more effective.
Surprisingly, patients with high-risk cytogenetics, a typically poor prognostic factor in multiple myeloma, were equally represented in both the long-term remission group and the group that progressed after Siltacel treatment. This suggests CAR-T therapy may overcome traditional risk stratification.
Data from J&J's Majestic 3 trial suggests its off-the-shelf bispecific combination could rival the efficacy of its own blockbuster CAR-T, Carvykti. This sets up an internal competition where a more accessible therapy could challenge a complex, personalized one in earlier lines of treatment.
T-cell receptor (TCR) therapies offer a significant advantage over monoclonal antibodies by targeting intracellular proteins. They recognize peptides presented on the cell surface, effectively unlocking 90% of the proteome and requiring far fewer target molecules (5-10 copies vs. 1000+) to kill a cancer cell.
An innovative strategy for solid tumors involves using bispecific T-cell engagers to target the tumor stroma—the protective fibrotic tissue surrounding the tumor. This novel approach aims to first eliminate this physical barrier, making the cancer cells themselves more vulnerable to subsequent immune attack.
The efficacy of Siltacel stems from a powerful initial expansion that eliminates cancer upfront. The CAR-T cells are often undetectable beyond six months, indicating their curative potential comes from an overwhelming initial response rather than persistent, long-term immune policing of the disease.
The future of medicine isn't about finding a single 'best' modality like CAR-T or gene therapy. Instead, it's about strategic convergence, choosing the right tool—be it a bispecific, ADC, or another biologic—based on the patient's specific disease stage and urgency of treatment.
The success of CAR-T therapy hinges on the quality of the patient's own lymphocytes. Procuring T-cells earlier in the disease course, before they become exhausted from numerous prior therapies, results in a higher proportion of naive T-cells, leading to better CAR-T cell manufacturing and clinical outcomes.
Bi-specific T-cell engagers (BiTEs) are highly immunogenic because the mechanism activating T-cells to kill cancer also primes them to mount an immune response against the drug itself. This 'collateral effect' is an inherent design challenge for this drug class.
A key breakthrough in Colonia Therapeutics' early data is achieving profound CAR-T cell expansion without lymphodepleting chemotherapy. This dramatically improves the safety profile and patient experience, potentially moving CAR-T therapy from major academic centers to more accessible community oncology settings, thereby "democratizing" the treatment.
