Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

At a March 7, 2020 Harvard panel, Helen Branswell said she was startled that a long-feared pandemic was happening. Rick Burke took that seriously because she was not easily startled; over dinner she asked what STAT would do when staff got sick and predicted the Olympics would be canceled.

Related Insights

Rick Burke says he was unsure whether STAT needed an infectious disease reporter on his first day. A respected journalist told him Helen Branswell was the best in the world, so he hired her anyway. That choice put top talent ahead of a predefined beat.

Host Scott Galloway recounts how an epidemiologist's stark COVID-19 warning prompted him to immediately close his office and relocate his family. This highlights the value of trusting and acting on expert insight, even when it seems alarmist or premature.

Analysts, economists, and thought leaders have a professional incentive to make pessimistic, catastrophic predictions. Optimistic forecasts of gradual improvement are less interesting and don't command high speaking fees or media attention, creating a systemic bias towards negativity in public discourse.

Galloway explains that the true goal of business forecasting is not exact predictive accuracy, but catalyzing conversations that guide strategic planning and scenario analysis. However, forecasters face a paradox: when an initially provocative prediction proves correct—such as Amazon acquiring Whole Foods or WeWork's IPO being pulled—the outcome appears self-evident in hindsight, diminishing the credit the forecaster receives for identifying non-obvious outcomes before they materialized.

When facing a crisis like COVID, waiting for perfect data before acting is not a 'safe' option. The status quo of inaction often carries its own significant, accumulating costs—like student learning loss—that must be factored into the decision.

Effective risk management focuses on preparing for various potential outcomes, not on trying to accurately predict the future. This proactive "what if" planning enables quicker, more decisive action when a crisis hits, making you seem prescient when you're actually just prepared.

Rochelle Walensky recalls Helen Branswell reporting that the CDC released a new Delta policy 'but she didn't show us the data.' Walensky later called Helen when the data came out; she trusted Helen because her agenda was getting the science right, not headlines or clicks.

Alex Hogan says early in the pandemic Helen Branswell was on the phone correcting an expert about new cases. After hanging up, she quietly said to no one, 'we're so fucked.' Hogan knew she did not catastrophize, so that private reaction told him COVID would become world-changing.

Rick Burke says he had never seen a reporter so careful and meticulous about where information comes from. During COVID, Helen Branswell was never overstated or alarmist, but she was direct with facts, and Burke says that made her sound authoritative to him again and again.

In a 2022 STAT video, Helen Branswell said misinformation and political muckraking made the pandemic worse. She described a balancing act: deciding when not to amplify something untrue, because even trying to poke holes in false information still disseminates it. She said it was hard to know when to ignore a claim and move on.

Prescient reporting requires seriousness, not alarmism | RiffOn