A major disconnect exists between Wall Street and Main Street. While jobs data points towards a potential recession, the S&P 500 is hitting record highs. Since recessions are historically preceded by market downturns, investors are signaling a strong disbelief in the negative labor market signals.

Related Insights

The official unemployment rate is misleadingly low because when disgruntled workers give up looking for a job, they exit the labor force and are no longer counted as 'unemployed.' This artificially improves the headline number while masking underlying economic weakness and anger among young job seekers.

While the headline number of job openings in the JOLTS report appears strong, it's a misleading signal. A record-low quits rate indicates workers are frozen in their jobs and lack confidence in the labor market, painting a picture of stagnation rather than dynamism.

Contrary to popular belief, the US already underwent a recession in early 2024, particularly for the average consumer ("Main Street"). This was masked by the AI sector boom and soaring asset prices. Revised labor data supports this view, and the economy is now in a reacceleration phase.

Large-cap tech earnings are hitting record highs, driving stock indices up. Simultaneously, core economic indicators for small businesses and high-yield borrowers show they have been in a recession-like state for over a year, creating a stark divergence.

Crossmark's Chief Market Strategist identifies investor complacency as her primary concern. The market's collective belief that earnings will continue to support upward momentum, despite underlying risks, creates a dangerous environment where investors are unprepared for shocks.

Despite record market highs, the S&P 500's underlying earnings per share (EPS) have not yet recovered to their peak from early 2022. This "narrative violation" points to a hidden earnings recession for large-cap stocks, a fact that has been masked by market enthusiasm and multiple expansion.

The economy is now driven by high-income earners whose spending fluctuates with the stock market. Unlike historical recessions, a significant market downturn is now a prerequisite for a broader economic recession, as equities must fall to curtail spending from this key demographic.

While large-cap tech props up the market, ADP employment data shows the small business sector has experienced negative job growth in six of the last seven months. This deep divergence highlights a "K-shaped" economy where monetary policy benefits large corporations at the expense of Main Street.

While headline corporate profits have stalled, adjusting them for the direct tax impact of tariffs reveals a sharp ~10% decline. The stock market's continued rally in the face of this profit compression signifies a major disconnect from fundamentals, suggesting equities are significantly mispriced.

Pundits predicting a recession based on dwindling consumer savings are missing the bigger picture: a $178 trillion household net worth. This massive wealth cushion, 6x the size of the US economy, allows for sustained spending even with low income growth, explaining why recent recession calls have failed.

Record-High Stock Market Directly Contradicts Alarming Labor Market Data | RiffOn